Unbiased analysis of two arguments created by stakeholders

Assignment Help English
Reference no: EM131091048

Prof Dan

Purpose

In Project Two, you will learn how to present an unbiased analysis of two arguments created by stakeholders with seemingly incompatible goals about an issue or topic and create a feasible, objective compromise that would benefit both stakeholders.

Project Description:

You will write a 1,200 - 1,500 word essay based on the following requirements:

  • analyze two stakeholders with seemingly incompatible goals regarding the same issue or topic
  • provide background on the stakeholders (context)
  • include a thesis that presents the point of contention between the stakeholders and explains a proposed compromise
  • identify why these two stakeholders have not yet come to a resolution
  • find common ground between these two stakeholders by considering what both have in common
  • suggest one particular, concrete compromise and defend this compromise by considering
  • the stated goals and concerns of both stakeholders,
  • current or past solutions, and
  • the feasibility of your solution's implementation
  • defend this solution as a workable compromise
  • use at least five sources according to the following guidelines:
  • At least one primary source material from each two stakeholders being discussed (i.e., information from the stakeholder websites, etc.)
  • At least one credible, scholarly source for each stakeholder that supports the validity of the stakeholder's position
  • At least one credible, scholarly source that supports the viability of the student's proposed compromise

Assessment:

This project will be evaluated using the Project 2: Finding Common Ground Rubric.

Role of Peer Review

Using MyReviewers, you will provide feedback via peer review. The peer review process allows you to respond to your peers' drafts as fellow writers working toward the common goal of producing properly formatted, useful and insightful essays based on the FYC Rubric. Both you and your peers will be using each other's comments and recommendations to improve your work. Thus, your individual commitment to peer review has a real impact on the success of the entire class.

Assignment:

In a 1,200-1,500 word essay, students will explain the perspectives of two different stakeholders on a given issue or topic, identifies common ground the two stakeholders share, and proposes and argues for a compromise that benefits both stakeholders. Students should clearly identify both stakeholders, fairly represent their perspectives using evidence, and posit a way for these two groups to reach common ground. Building on this common ground, students should also clearly argue for a solution that would allow both groups to reach a compromise on the issue or topic, provide contexts in which the compromise will work, and demonstrate that the compromise appeases both stakeholders.

Role of Research:

Research for this project will involve moving beyond the stakeholders themselves to a consideration of the issue or topic and a potential solution. Students may need to consider the following: basic historical information about the issue or topic; the factual accuracy of the stakeholders claims; research that supports the student's proposed solution; research that challenges or complicates the issue or topic or proposed solution; research about previously attempted solutions; other research surrounding the chosen issue or topic.

For this paper, the sources that must be quoted/cited include the following:

Primary source material from each of the two stakeholders being discussed (i.e., information from the stakeholder websites, etc.)
At least one credible, scholarly source for each stakeholder that supports the validity of the stakeholder's position
At least one credible, scholarly source that supports the viability of the student's proposed compromise.
In total, the minimum number of sources (and Works Cited citations) should be five: two primary sources from the stakeholders, one source per stakeholder supporting the stakeholder's position, and one source supporting the student's compromise.

Role of Peer Review:

In this project, peer review will be particularly valuable for writers because it will provide an outside perspective regarding students' biases. Moreover, students will engage with peers' writing to evaluate their empathy and assess their compromises, therefore reinforcing the empathy that this project fosters.

Writing Process:

Early Draft: Students will discuss their answers to the Project 2 Guiding Questions Worksheet in workshop, which includes a space for brainstorming possible solutions (e.g. media-based; legal-based; mindset-based). Students may use this space to outline, free-write, mind map, or otherwise thoughtfully express insightful ideas.

Intermediate Draft: The Intermediate Draft should be a working draft (1,200 - 1,500 words) that explains the perspectives of two different stakeholders on a given issue or topic, identifies common ground the two stakeholders share, and proposes and argues for a compromise that benefits both stakeholders. This draft should include a thesis, all major points, evidence to support these points (including in-text citations from appropriate sources), and a Works Cited page.

Final Draft: The Final Draft will be a polished essay (1,200 - 1,500 words) that explains the perspectives of two different stakeholders on a given issue or topic, identifies common ground the two stakeholders share, and proposes and argues for a compromise that benefits both stakeholders. This draft should include a thesis, all major points, evidence to support these points (including in-text citations from appropriate sources), and a Works Cited page. The document should be free of organizational, grammar, and style errors and should follow proper MLA structure both in formatting the paper and citing sources.

*Final drafts that have not been significantly revised will be lowered one letter grade.

*It is your responsibility to upload your project drafts to both Canvas and My Reviewers. Assignments will be counted as late until they have been turned into both sites.

Future Considerations

Project 2 fosters an understanding of viable compromises tailored specifically to the goals of two stakeholders with disparate objectives. With this developing ability to focus on the specific needs and abilities of an audience, in Project 3 students will make a call to action through which they will attempt to persuade an unengaged audience to become involved with the issue at hand. In doing so, students will consider what they learned in Project 1 about visual rhetoric and multimedia-based arguments, as well as how to make a call that their target audience not only can, but will do to become engaged with the topic. Students should consider: What might the chosen organization need from you? What kind of composition might help the organization achieve its purpose?

Reference no: EM131091048

Questions Cloud

Primary advantages of diversity in the workforce : What are the primary advantages of diversity in the workforce? Be specific with a summary of each one. Explain the three (3) main reasons for conducting performance appraisals. What is the key difference between BARS and the Graphic Rating Scale?
New cost-effective virtual methods of training : In 200-250 words,how has technology fostered new cost-effective virtual methods of training? In your view, how must training programs continue to evolve in order to do more with diminished financial resources?
Human resource professional : He was majoring in technology, but he had an internship in computer programming last year and was bored to tears. He felt the internship was a failure. If he came to you, a human resource professional, for advice, which would you tell him?
What is the nyquist rate for this signal : What is the Nyquist rate for this signal?
Unbiased analysis of two arguments created by stakeholders : In Project Two, you will learn how to present an unbiased analysis of two arguments created by stakeholders with seemingly incompatible goals about an issue or topic and create a feasible, objective compromise that would benefit both stakeholders.
Donuts betting dollars on donuts : Read the case Dunkin' Donuts Betting Dollars on Donuts beginning on page 451 of your text.
Objectives to achieve better planning and control : Put yourself in the position of a management trainer. You have been asked to make a short presentation to the local Small Business Enterprise Association at its biweekly luncheon. The topic you are to speak on is "How Each of You Can Use Objective..
Give responses for participation to each discussion : One of the potential ethical issues raised in this scenario could first be an issue of competence. It should be noted that Dr.X is specialized in criminal cases not custody evaluations.
Show that the fundamental period nr of the signals : Show that the fundamental period Nr of the signals

Reviews

Write a Review

English Questions & Answers

  Write a profile

Write a profile on bishop poleni.

  Education system

Write a rearch paper on education system

  Write an report

The U.S. President Barack Obama said America can "win the future" by rebuilding its manufacturing sector (on June 8, 2011, after visiting an automotive training center at a community college in Virginia, outside Washington). Do you agree, and why?

  Discuss the accuracy of this statement

'Consideration does not have to be adequate or commercially realistic, nor does it need to be expressed in monetary terms, it merely needs to be "sufficient".' Discuss the accuracy of this statement.

  Write an essay on the youngest billionaire

Write an essay on the youngest billionaire

  Transformational leadership in the public sector

The more hierarchical an organization's authority structure, the lower the reported practice of transformational leadership behaviors.

  Modal verbs or modal constructions

Identify all the modal verbs or modal constructions in the passage

  Write a latter to mom thanking to adopting and caring

Write a latter to mom thanking for adopting and caring,

  Ways of knowing & authority in your discipline

To explore and become familiar with your discipline; to prepare you for your major researched essay.

  Writing an effective business letter

Prepare a letter in either block or modified block format, addressed to your employer or supervisor and copied to your marker.

  Discuss the kingdom of saudi arabia

Discuss the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia

  Developing an annotated bibliography

Developing an annotated bibliography

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd