The dangers of punishing the defendant for the damage

Assignment Help Project Management

Reference no: EM131274731

In 2002, Mayola Williams, the widow of a man who smoked as many as 3 packs of Marlboro cigarettes a day for almost 50 years, sued Philip Morris USA for the torts of negligence and fraud. Williams's husband had eventually died from a smoking-related disease. Williams argued that the products produced by Philip Morris were a cause of her husband's death. The case was important because it could have redefined how large punitive damages ought to be against tobacco and other large and powerful corporations in product liability cases. In 2006, the Supreme Court of Oregon awarded Williams $800,000 in compensatory damages and $79.5 million in punitive damages.

Philip Morris appealed the court's decision, arguing that punitive damages should more equally fit the actual damages suffered. In other words, Philip Morris argued that the amount of the punitive damages should be based on the damages only the plaintiff in the instant case suffered, rather than any damages that other users of the product (who were not in court) might have suffered. What could be the dangers of punishing the defendant for the damage the defendant has caused to individuals who are not in court? How did the Supreme Court decide in this case?

Reference no: EM131274731

Questions Cloud

What is simple network management protocol : 1. What is Simple Network Management Protocol (SNMP)? 2. Describe SNMP Basics and Operations. 3. SNMP Cryptographic Fundamentals

Provides a road map that management can implement : The outline should not be a reiteration of motivation theory, but should provide succinct points that cover the key topics of motivation and provides a road map that management can implement to improve motivation within the organization.

What is the role of retained austenite in this case : Why is it that the strength of the heat-affected zone is higher for low-carbon steels? What is the role of retained austenite, in this case?

Determine the hardnesses expected at each point : Determine the hardnesses expected at each point if a 1080 steel were welded under the same conditions. Predict the microstructure at each location in the as-welded 1080 steel.

The dangers of punishing the defendant for the damage : What could be the dangers of punishing the defendant for the damage the defendant has caused to individuals who are not in court?

Explain the major components of your culture : Explain the various symbols associated with your culture including their meanings. Describe the other cultures you are integrated with besides your own. What are the similarities and differences between these cultures with which you are connected?

The court of appeals either granted or denied the appeal : The district court dismissed the suit, and the plaintiffs appealed. Why do you believe the court of appeals either granted or denied the appeal?

Describe darwins theory of natural selection : Describe Darwin's theory of natural selection. Explain the 4 main processes of population genetics & evolution. Explain the importance of mutation in natural selection. Describe mitosis & meiosis. Which is most important in evolution?

Sub-data management : When an update to the database takes place, the time of the update, the values of the data before and after the update, and the type of lock used are recorded in the transaction log. true or false?

User Account

All Pages