Reference no: EM13171385
"In a recent lecture at Yale University, Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer cautioned that while most citizens assume that judicial review is an enduring part of American government, judges should not take it for granted. He advises that if judges wish to preserve this undemocratic power they should follow a judicial philosophy that will "build confidence in the courts" (Breyer, 2011). Justice Breyer goes on to describe the kind of judicial philosophy he has in mind. However, some of his colleagues on the Supreme Court would reject his ideas about what philosophy should guide judges.
The role of judicial philosophy (or ideology) in Supreme Court decision-making, especially in its exercise of judicial review to invalidate laws enacted by a democratically elected Congress or state legislature, has become a highly contentious issue both within the Court's deliberations and in the larger political environment. As the nation becomes more divided over programs and policies that inevitably seem to come before the Supreme Court, politicians and ordinary citizens are caught up in rhetoric about judicial activism or judicial restraint, often with little understanding of what these terms really mean.
Moreover, as public perceptions of the Supreme Court become more politicized, the legitimacy of its power becomes clouded. If the Court is perceived as just another political institution making political decisions, but a completely undemocratic institution because its judges are appointed and serve for life, questions arise about whether the Court's power of judicial review should be strictly limited or eliminated altogether. Justice Breyer's warning comes to mind as the percent of Americans approving of how the Supreme Court does its job slid from 61% in 2009 to 46% in 2011 (Gallup, 2012).
In your initial post of at least 200-250 words, respond to one of these questions:
What judicial philosophy should guide the Supreme Court's exercise of judicial review?
Should the Supreme Court's power of judicial review be strictly limited by a constitutional amendment?
In answering either question, clearly state your position (thesis) at the beginning of your post. Define important terms and explain your position fully. Consider pro and con arguments on both sides of your position and respond to the con arguments. Justify your position with facts and persuasive reasoning.
|
Elements of advanced information technology
: As the Acetate Department introduced more elements of advanced information technology, compare the management implications that were achieved to what they could have achieved, according to the textbook.
|
|
Conference calls useful type of virtual meeting
: I couldn't agree more, DJ. In a past position, we had monthly conference call meetings with dozens of people. I always found them to be frustrating because I never knew who was speaking or when it was my turn to speak. They were not managed effective..
|
|
Historical development of leadership theories
: Explain the historical development of leadership theories in the 20th century. How do they build on one another? What was the purpose of the 2004 GLOBE studies?
|
|
Argument for specific conclusion
: Construct an inductive argument for a specific conclusion. Then, explain what you might do to make this inductive argument stronger, either by revising the premises or by revising the conclusion.
|
|
Supreme court''s exercise of judicial review
: What judicial philosophy should guide the Supreme Court's exercise of judicial review? Should the Supreme Court's power of judicial review be strictly limited by a constitutional amendment?
|
|
Description of each stage of development
: Give a description of each stage of development (Erickson's theory). Note: Remember to include a description of a character that represents each stage of development.
|
|
Analysis of environmental public policy
: What are some factors considered when conducting benefit-cost analysis of environmental public policy? Why has the amount of municipal solid waste in the United States grown steadily?
|
|
Why is there need for environmental public policy
: What will a "sustainable economy" look like? Why do production and consumption represent "just part" of an economic system? Why is there a need for environmental public policy?
|
|
According to national survey data-share of adults
: According to national survey data, what share of adults in the United States state that a woman should be able to obtain an abortion for any reason?
|