Summarize the corroborative and contradictory audit evidence

Assignment Help Accounting Basics
Reference no: EM132588897

Contradictory Evidence

Auditors have a responsibility to remain alert to audit evidence that contradicts other audit evidence obtained. The application of professional skepticism is essential to the critical assessment and questioning of contradictory audit evidence. When the auditor obtains information during the course of the audit that contradicts information obtained from another source, the auditor has a responsibility to resolve the matter and consider its impact on the sufficiency and appropriateness of audit evidence obtained and the effect, if any, on other aspects of the audit. The auditor may face significant challenges associated with identifying, evaluating, and addressing contrary, disconfirming, or inconsistent evidence. In particular, when auditing accounting estimates, auditors may have a tendency to overweight evidence that is supportive of management's methods and assumptions, favoring evidence that confirms the aforementioned, without critically assessing the reasonableness of contradictory evidence or inputs.

The following case illustrates how the auditor considers audit evidence obtained, including contradictory evidence, related to accounting estimates.

A commercial furniture wholesaler reserves for its allowance for doubtful accounts based on standard reserve percentages supported by historical collection experience. (Note that this example does not contemplate the need for specific reserves.) Management uses the same process for estimating the allowance for doubtful accounts (the "reserve"), as it did in the prior year. As part of its risk assessment procedures, the engagement team identified the following risk of material misstatement related to the valuation assertion:

  • The entity may not appropriately update its reserve policy (including updates to reserve percentages) for changes in circumstances.

Note that the engagement team may have identified additional risks of material misstatement related to the valuation assertion identified as part of its risk assessment procedures; however, this example focuses on this specific risk of material misstatement for illustrative purposes. In addition, this risk was not identified as a fraud risk.

The engagement team obtained the following evidence from the audit procedures performed to address this risk:

  • The current-year reserve as a percentage of gross receivables is consistent with prior years, although there was an increase in revenues, gross receivables, and the related reserve.
  • Bad debt expense has remained consistent as a percentage of gross revenue over the past several years.
  • Retrospective review of receivable collections indicates that management's reserves have historically been accurate.
  • Economic conditions have been fairly stable and are predicted to remain stable.
  • Revenues increased substantially year over year as a result of the introduction of a new product line.
  • The new product line is marketed toward customers in the restaurant industry, in which the entity does not currently have an established customer base.
  • The restaurant industry generally has a higher rate of business failure than other customer segments.
  • The entity's collections experience has primarily been with customers in the retail and professional services industries; the entity has very little collections experience with the new product line, given the recent launch.
  • Approved sales terms have not changed year to year (e.g., sales personnel may offer an extension of credit of up to 100 percent of the purchase price consistent with prior year, creditworthiness is determined in the same manner, payment terms are consistent with prior year).
  • Sales of the new product line are more frequently 100 percent financed versus sales of the existing product lines, resulting in an increase in gross receivables.
  • Competitors who manufacture similar restaurant furniture products have higher reserves as a percentage of their trade receivables.

Required: For each case above:

Question 1. Identify and summarize the corroborative and contradictory audit evidence in each scenario.

Question 2. Determine what additional information, if any, is needed to reach a conclusion regarding management's assertion.

Question 3. On the basis of the case facts, determine whether management's assertion is supportable and how additional information obtained might change your conclusion.

Reference no: EM132588897

Questions Cloud

What time-gobbling activities can you eliminate : Who in your support system can assist you? What else needs to happen to help you in re-claiming your time?
Estimate how much baltimore company should report : Estimate how much Baltimore Company should report for its investment in Towson Company on December 31, 2018. (Round to the nearest dollar.)
New speaker for using more inclusive language : What are some tips that you might give a new speaker for using more inclusive language?
Designed classroom management plan : How will you collect data on the effectiveness of your designed classroom management plan to make continuous improvements?
Summarize the corroborative and contradictory audit evidence : Case facts, determine whether management's assertion is supportable and how additional information obtained might change your conclusion.
Create a budget showing the expected current profit : Create a budget showing the expected current profit and profit after the changes in costs.Fixed costs are increased to $75,000.
List six words that signal a broad generalization : List six words that signal a broad generalization and a recommended alternative that would resolve that problem of each.
Determine amount of impairment that lewis would recognize : Determine the amount of impairment that Lewis would recognize for these two loans. (Round your final answers to 1 decimal place)
How are presentations and interviews similar : How are presentations and interviews similar? Consider how you can apply presentation skills in an interview situation.

Reviews

Write a Review

Accounting Basics Questions & Answers

  Compute the cost to manufacture one unit of product

The beginning work-in-process inventory was $6,000; the ending work-in-process inventory was $5,000. Assume that 1,000 units were produced during the month.

  Continuous cycle-managerial accounting

Define planning, organizing, and controlling and then explain why the phases of planning, organizing, and controlling are referred to as a continuous cycle?

  Compute the direct labor quantity variance

Last month, 12,000 units were produced and 70,000 direct labor hours were actually worked at a total cost of $1,020,000. Compute direct labor quantity variance

  Xyz inc had actual sales of 150000 in february and 160000

xyz inc. had actual sales of 150000 in february and 160000 in march. the firms managers estimate that sales in april

  Accurate information to marketing decision makers

1) ________ consists of people, equipment, and procedures to gather, sort, analyze, evaluate, and distribute needed, timely, and accurate information to marketing decision makers.

  G and l form a limited partnership

G and L form a limited partnership. G, the general partner, contributes $80,000 and L, the limited partner, contributes $320,000. The partnership purchases commercial real estate on leased land, paying $4000,000 cash and borrowing $1,600,000 on a ..

  What is the total deposit rachel expects the bank to deposit

What is the total deposit Rachel expects the bank to deposit into her account after the total bank fees and charges are taken out of credit purchases on Monday?

  Describe the implications of the information after you have

budgeting is an important internal activity. preparing budgets involve forecasting sales and estimating costs. for this

  Would you place more emphasis on auditing cash or land

When conducting an audit, would you place more emphasis on auditing cash or land and buildings?

  Prepare the adjusting entry for inventory counts

While testing the inventory counts, the auditors noticed that several high dollar items had counts on the inventory listing which were materially higher than the actual counts. The difference between the actual and recorded inventory value was $66..

  Reeves inc sold 1000000 shares of 25 par value common stock

reeves inc. sold 1000000 shares of 25 par value common stock at 30. it subsequently repurchased 100000 of those shares

  Which was a larger profit than b had originally budgeted

which was a $200,000 larger profit than B had originally budgeted for the sale to A. A has now filed suit to recover the $400,000 deposit.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd