Spite of the problematic nature of such endeavor

Assignment Help History
Reference no: EM133530857

Thomas Haskell believes that objectivity in history is an ideal that should be pursued in spite of the problematic nature of such an endeavor.

Haskell suggests that, instead of convincing those who already agree with your perspective, you should seek out those who disagree with you: Remaining neutral is not the role of the historian. By taking this position, Haskell is disagreeing with Novick, who claims that objectivity is neutrality and argues that "historians, as historians, must purge themselves of external loyalties" (1988, 2). In contrast, Haskell claims that "[t]o be dissatisfied with the view of the world as it initially appears to us, and to struggle to formulate a superior, more inclusive, less self-centered alternative, is to strive for detachment and aim at objectivity" (1990, 132).

Aargue a position in terms of the objectivity question. Is the goal of the historian to act as an activist or a judge? Or should the historian impartially report on the past? Is there potential for compromise between these two extremes? Use specific examples drawn from Haskell's article.

Reference no: EM133530857

Questions Cloud

Why are they the most important challenges : What challenges are mentioned in the case? Focus on what you believe to be the 2-3 most important challenges and describe them. Why are they the most important
Describe the philosophical position of determinism : Describe the philosophical position of determinism while considering the practical consequences of assuming both positions of determinism and free will.
Explain how your instructional strategies-accommodations : Explain how your instructional strategies, accommodations, modifications, and assessments(s) address the needs of English Learners, including Nancy.
What does the public budgeting systems textbook : what does the "Public Budgeting Systems"textbook say in regards to the following. What is a recession? Describe the fiscal and monetary policy responses
Spite of the problematic nature of such endeavor : Thomas Haskell believes that objectivity in history is an ideal that should be pursued in spite of the problematic nature of such an endeavor.
Create what will become the opening of your paper : Create what will become the opening of your paper. Outline the main points of the rest of your paper after the introduction.
Internet gambling-develop paper by gathering information : Internet Gambling-Develop a paper by gathering information on the growing problem of Internet gambling on campus
Prepare the consolidation worksheet entries as at 30 june : Prepare the consolidation worksheet entries as at 30 June 2023 to adjust for the effects of the above inter-entity transactions. Include dates for each entry.
How the terms of rhetoric helped you plan : Discuss in a couple of sentences how the terms of rhetoric helped you plan and draft this essay. Think of A.R.E. and the rhetorical appeals as you write this.

Reviews

Write a Review

History Questions & Answers

  Position in the argumentative essay

What methods (keyword searches, limiting your search, etc.) will you use to make your research most effective?

  What do you know about the author

Who created the source? What do you know about the author? What is the author's point of view?Where and when was the source produced? How might this affect the meaning of the source?Beyond information about the author and the context of its creation,..

  The evolution of america from isolationism

The social characteristics, such as opportunities for women and minorities, internment of Japanese Americans, demographic shifts, leisure activities, and others

  Explain what role did government play in these developments

What role did government play in these developments? How did your chosen group ( Immigrants ) respond to those changes, and how effective were their responses?

  What does it mean to be metis why has columbus day become

What does it mean to be Metis? Why has Columbus Day become one of the most controversial holidays in the US? Describe some the most profound consequences

  What is the difference between modernism

What is the difference between modernism, impressionism, and post-impressionism?

  Argument video that has committed a fallacy

What is the best way to find an argument video that has committed a fallacy? What type of arguments should I be searching for

  Affect women''s career decisions

The textbook states that the place for women in the latter half of the nineteenth century seemed to be the home. Is this statement accurate for most European women? How did economic considerations affect women's career decisions?

  First european-wide conflict

It has been argued that the Thirty Years' War was the first European-wide conflict. Do you agree? What was the outcome of the war?

  The iconic photo of the great depression

Write a paragraph about the   The iconic photo of the Great Depression was taken by Dorothea Lange in March 1936 and entitled “Migrant Mother.” The photo portrays pea pickers in California, and the woman is a 32-year-old mother of seven children.  ..

  How the business contributes to the community

How the business contributes to the community. Describe the actions of the business and what you think are the effects in a 3 p@ragraph essay.

  What great battle was the trojan horse involved in

What great battle was the trojan horse involved in?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd