Should we trust our government to make these decisions

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM131830984

Let's say that Tom, who is 25 years old, wants to smoke a cigarette. Consider the following two situations.

a. Tom is smoking. Suddenly, the government comes along and tells Tom that he cannot do this. The government claims that Tom is inflicting an "external cost" on other human beings. Is this a good policy or bad policy?

b. Tom is smoking a cigarette at home with no one else around. Suddenly, the government comes along and tells Tom that he cannot do this. The government claims that Tom is inflicting an "external cost" on another human being. Tom asks who this might be?

The government says that the 65-year-old Tom will be harmed by the smoking today-Tom.

The government claims that today-Tom isn't doing enough to look out for the well-being of future-Tom. Does this argument make any sense? Is it ethically correct? If so, can and should we trust our government to make these decisions for our future selves?

Reference no: EM131830984

Questions Cloud

Is this inequality better or worse : Is this inequality better or worse than if one person is born into a rich family and the other is born into a poor family?

Main effects and interactions and standard errors : For the following data calculate the main effects and interactions and their standard errors. The 24 trials were run in random order.

How does the given situation serve as an analogy : Suppose there is a small commercial retail building in town. How does this situation serve as an analogy for the concept of IP addresses with TCP port numbers?

What can economics tell us about the ideal number of people : Would this make for a better India or a worse India? Although each Indian would have much more, there would be fewer Indians.

Should we trust our government to make these decisions : The government claims that today-Tom isn't doing enough to look out for the well-being of future-Tom. Does this argument make any sense?

Pharmacological effects of nalbuphine : The measured response obtained from 11 subjects was the change in pupil diameter (in millimeters) after 28 doses of nalbuphine (B) or morphine (A):

What are the implications of having such a small field size : Given that this hop count is reduced each time an IP datagram enters a router, what are the implications of having such a small field size?

Identify which of the three grounds for avoiding a contract : Case - Commercial Bank of Australia Ltd v Amadio [1983]. identify which of the three grounds for avoiding a contract given in those notes Amadios relied upon

Confidence interval for the true difference between : Include in your answer a calculated 95% confidence interval for the true difference between the volumes obtained with A and B. State any assumptions you make.

User Account

All Pages