Should they torture the prisoner

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM13982229

To Torture or Not to Torture

Note: In order to fulfill this assignment, you need to have read chapters 5-7, 14 from the Holmes text. If you have not done so, please stop now and read that material.

One of the ethical controversies of recent times is the practice of using torture in obtaining information from suspected terrorists or those with knowledge of terrorist activities. Some believe that the current threat of terrorism warrants such drastic means while others believe that torture is never a justifiable manner in handling prisoners of war.

Suppose a situation presents itself in which we have strong reasons to believe a major attack on U.S. soil is immanent and that many lives will be put in danger. Security forces have captured a terrorist whom they have very good reasons to believe has vital information that can lead to thwarting this attack. They have tried the usual means of obtaining information from the prisoner and none of them have been successful. His resolve not to talk is quite strong. However, security forces now consider torturing the prisoner and believe with a high degree of probability that his resolve will be broken and he will supply the needed information. Should they torture the prisoner?

Reference no: EM13982229

Questions Cloud

Monopolists demand curve and the cost information : The table below shows a monopolist’s demand curve and the cost information for the production of its good. What will their profits equal? Quantity: 10,20,30,40 Price per unit: 100,80,60,40,20 Total Cost: 100,400,800,1400,2400
How long on average does it take an electron to travel : If the current through the wire is 2.0 A , how long on average does it take an electron to travel from the switch at the pedal to one of the brake lights? The number density of free electrons in copper is n = 8.4 x 1028 electrons/m3. Suppose that ..
Models of operations and information management : Critically analyse the theory, concepts and models of operations and information management and demonstrate an understanding of the strategic importance of information management in global organisations.
What is the ratio of the signal strength measured : Observer B is on the street, with a direct-line distance of only 169 m from the antenna. What is the ratio of the signal strength measured by B, IB, to that measured by A, IA?
Should they torture the prisoner : Suppose a situation presents itself in which we have strong reasons to believe a major attack on U.S. soil is immanent and that many lives will be put in danger. Should they torture the prisoner
What is the net advantage or disadvantage to the company : The Tingey Company has 500 obsolete microcomputers that are carried in inventory at a total cost of $720,000. If these microcomputers are upgraded at a total cost of $100,000, they can be sold for a total of $160,000.
Find the magnitude of the magnetic field inside the toroid : The figure shows a toroid with N total turns and a current I . Apply Ampere's Law to find the magnitude of the magnetic field inside the toroid and at a distance r from the axis of the toroid. [Make sure you draw a diagram to show the Amperian loo..
Value-enhancing project to the company : How do managers know whether this project is a value-enhancing project to the company? What is the appropriate capital budgeting tool to analyze the benefits of the project?
How has new york city changed in recent decades : How has New York City changed in recent decades? Do you think it is a better place to live now than it was in the past? If you were a poor immigrant coming to New York City, during which period of history - from the colonial period to the present ..

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Different religious and philosophical traditions

How can different religious/philosophical traditions be understood as contributing to a shared human conversation about moral questions such as how one should conceive of their place in the world and relationship to others

  Provide perspective on significance of group counseling

Provide your perspective on the significance of group counseling. Explain how group members might benefit from their participation in group work. Explain why group work is emphasized in professional counseling literature.

  Importance of integrating technology

Discuss the importance of integrating technology into the career development process and name two types of technology that support this process.

  Turkey position in these issues

NATO Simulation: What is Turkey's position in these issues? (academic sources are required to answer these questions) (one page at least for each question with appropriate and correct answer)

  Employee turnover rate is becoming a major concern

Southeastern Oklahoma State University is growing university; however, professor and employee turnover rate is becoming a major concern. They are currently working on their pay structure, should they conduct a survey for this? Support your answer.

  Describe the basic steps for conducting a literature search

Describe the basic steps for conducting a literature search. What is one of the challenges you have faced in selecting the appropriate journal articles for your review

  Problem regrading the arketing research paper

Kudler Fine Foods is a gourmet grocery store that has experienced significant growth and is now focused on expanding its services, improving the efficiency of its operations, and increasing the consumer purchase cycle.

  What types of stylistic-proofs were used to gain credibility

Please view the video of Obama's 2004 Democratic National Convention (DNC) speech and address the following: How did the speaker's style affect your overall reaction to the speech? What types of stylistic-proofs were used to gain credibility? What..

  Compare and synthesize the research

The objective is to integrate, compare and synthesize the research so that you are looking at the same question on different dimensions and with different tools. This is how research is done.

  Kinds of contracts

Raj went to the Napa Valley Harvest Festival, where he stopped at Tina's booth where she was selling paintings of vineyards. Raj admired a painting of vineyards.

  As the rate of innovation increases companies face

as the rate of innovation increases companies face expanding productservice lines shorter product and service

  How has the unethical behavior affected the organization

1.what unethical research behavior was involved?2.who were the injured parties?3.how has the unethical behavior

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd