Should the u.s. government that sponsored the experiments

Reference no: EM133457023

Case Study: In 1944, the medical team of the Manhattan Project agreed to conduct secret radiation-exposure experiments at four U.S. hospitals in an effort to develop safety guidelines for Manhattan Project workers.

Between 1945 and 1947, 18 patients in these hospitals who were diagnosed (and in some cases, misdiagnosed) with terminal illnesses and expected to live no longer than 10 years were injected with plutonium. Of these, just one is known to have signed a consent form (Atomic Heritage Foundation, 2017). Seven patients lived longer than 10 years, and five lived more than 20 years. The remaining survivors were not notified that they had been injected with plutonium until 1974 (Subcommittee on Energy Conservation and Power, Committee on Energy and Commerce, U.S. House of Representatives, 1986).

Discussion Activity

Questions: For this discussion, consider the following questions:

Whose interests were served by the decision not to tell the participants they had been injected with plutonium?
Should the participants have been informed of their radiation exposure even though they might have been alarmed by this disclosure (thus possibly compromising quality of life)?
Is research on people without their informed consent ever permissible, even in the interests of national security or in times of war?
Should the U.S. government that sponsored the experiments be expected to make financial reparations to the survivors or their next of kin?

Reference no: EM133457023

Questions Cloud

Explain how you will use resources to network in your local : Explain how you will use resources to network in your local health care community (e.g., volunteering, job shadowing, staying up to date with organizations

Which extent italian society and family tradition influences : To which extent Italian society and family tradition influences the personal choices and private life of each member/charachter of the Cantone's family in the f

How will the information you found on the organization : What specific resources on the organization's website do you find interesting or helpful? Why? If the organization offers scholarships, which would you qualify

Ability to work with and understand historical documents : Has a relevant thesis and supports that thesis with evidence from the documents. Identifies and explains the need for at least one additional type of document.

Should the u.s. government that sponsored the experiments : Whose interests were served by the decision not to tell the participants they had been injected with plutonium? Should the participants have been informed

Identifying information for the quality assurance meeting : Identifying Information for the quality assurance meeting and That means this identifying information should be included in the minutes of IQA meeting

Difference in way both powers faced defeat : Explain in what ways this element shows a similarity or demonstrates a difference in the way both powers faced defeat.

Discuss areas of concern for a healthcare administrator : Provide a brief description of your selected critical area of interest and the initiative you have researched from one of the above sites.

Technology affect the expansion of powerful states : How did industrialization, science, and technology affect the expansion of powerful states into the rest of the world? Explain

User Account

All Pages