Should the exclusionary rule continue to be a constitutional

Reference no: EM133613689

Discussion Post

The 4th Amendment prevents the federal government from searching unreasonably but did not include a remedy. In Weeks v. U.S., the Supreme Court decided that the evidence that was unlawfully obtained must be excluded in any trial against the aggrieved defendant. The justices determined that the 4th Amendment, despite the absence of specific language, was meaningless unless the evidence was suppressed. More recent cases have trended towards limiting, or some would say abolishing, this "Exclusionary Rule."

Answer the following questions:

Question A. Should the Exclusionary Rule continue to be a Constitutional mandate of the 4th Amendment? What if the result is dismissal of charges against a clearly guilty defendant?

Question B. If the Exclusionary Rule is abolished by the Supreme Court, how should 4th Amendment violations be resolved? If we are no longer going to exclude reliable evidence of the defendant's guilt that was obtained in violation of 4th Amendment protections, how do we hold law enforcement accountable?

Reference no: EM133613689

Questions Cloud

Describe the components of the nursing theory : Describe the components of the nursing theory. Explain how you will incorporate this nursing theory into your nursing practice. Include rationales and examples.

Clearly explain the meaning of the word of the year : Clearly explain the meaning of the Word of the Year. Provide 4-5 examples of cultural events that led up to or evolved from this word usage.

Discuss successful systems of communication that were used : Discuss 2 successful systems of communication that were used in the organization in which you worked during this change initiative.

He is making argument from tradition : He is making an argument from popularity. Because of a framing effect. He is making an argument from tradition.

Should the exclusionary rule continue to be a constitutional : Should the Exclusionary Rule continue to be a Constitutional mandate of 4th Amendment? What if result is dismissal of charges against clearly guilty defendant?

Based on analysis of cadbury strategy : Based on your analysis of Cadbury's strategy and of the proposed acquisition, determine if you support the acquisition

Social security retirement benefit : Social Security Retirement benefit was intended to be one leg of a "three-legged stool."

Discuss a change initiative that you are familiar with : Discuss a change initiative that you are familiar with, using the force-field analysis model. Create headings for topics and sub-topics.

What research methodology is appropriate : You are asked to interview people to ask them about their experience during the COVID-19 pandemic. What research methodology is appropriate.

User Account

All Pages