Should the case be transferred to a south carolina venue

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics
Reference no: EM131110025

1. A Question of Ethics-Copyrights. Steven Soderbergh is the Academy Award-winning director of Erin Brockovich, Traffic, and many other films. CleanFlicks, LLC, filed a suit in a federal district court against Soderbergh, fifteen other directors, and the Directors Guild of America. The plaintiff asked the court to rule that it had the right to sell DVDs of the defendants' films altered without the defendants' consent to delete scenes of "sex, nudity, profanity and gory violence." CleanFlicks sold or rented the edited DVDs under the slogan "It's About Choice" to consumers, sometimes indirectly through retailers. It would not sell to retailers that made unauthorized copies of the edited films. The defendants, with DreamWorks LLC and seven other movie studios that own the copyrights to the films, filed a counterclaim against CleanFlicks and others engaged in the same business, alleging copyright infringement. Those filing the counterclaim asked the court to enjoin (prevent) CleanFlicks and the others from making and marketing altered versions of the films. [CleanFlicks of Colorado, LLC v. Soderbergh, 433 FSupp.2d 1236 (D.Colo. 2006)] (See Making Ethical Business Decisions .)

Movie studios often edit their films to conform to content and other standards and sell the edited versions to network television and other commercial buyers. In this case, however, the studios objected when CleanFlicks edited the films and sold the altered versions directly to consumers. Similarly, CleanFlicks made unauthorized copies of the studios' DVDs to edit the films, but objected when others made unauthorized copies of the altered versions. Is there anything unethical about these apparently contradictory positions? Why or why not?

2. CleanFlicks and its competitors asserted, in part, that they were making "fair use" of the studios' copyrighted works. They argued that by their actions "they are criticizing the objectionable content commonly found in current movies and that they are providing more socially acceptable alternatives to enable families to view the films together, without exposing children to the presumed harmful effects emanating from the objectionable content." If you were the judge, how would you view this argument? Is a court the appropriate forum for making determinations of public or social policy? Explain.

Venue. Brandy Austin used powdered infant formula to feed her infant daughter shortly after her birth. Austin claimed that a can of Nestlé Good Start Supreme Powder Infant Formula was contaminated with Enterobacter sakazakii bacteria, which can cause infections of the bloodstream and central nervous system, in particular, meningitis (inflammation of the tissue surrounding the brain or spinal cord). Austin filed an action against Nestlé in Hennepin County District Court in Minnesota. Nestlé argued for a change of venue because the alleged tortious action on the part of Nestlé occurred in South Carolina. Austin is a South Carolina resident and gave birth to her daughter in that state. Should the case be transferred to a South Carolina venue? Why or why not? [Austin v. Nestle USA, Inc., 677 F.Supp.2d 1134 (D.Minn. 2009)] (See What if the Facts were Different?.)

Reference no: EM131110025

Questions Cloud

Discuss the sun is causing most of the warming of the earth : Discuss The sun is causing most of the warming of the Earth. A very good website that discusses some of these topics is the Skeptical Science website.
Create a method to iterate through the list : Create a method to iterate through the list and have the three characters jump each of the heights contained in the list.
What is the conversion ratio for each of the following bonds : What is the conversion ratio for each of the following bonds? a. A $1,000-par-value bond that is convertible into common stock at $43.75 per share. b. A $1,000-par-value bond that is convertible into common stock at $25 per share. c. A $600-par-value..
What disclosures should be made by lessees and lessors : What disclosures should be made by lessees and lessors related to future lease payments?
Should the case be transferred to a south carolina venue : Austin is a South Carolina resident and gave birth to her daughter in that state. Should the case be transferred to a South Carolina venue? Why or why not
What makes some healthy and others ill : Determinants fall into five categories, including: a) policy making, b) social factors, c) health services, d) individual behavior, and e) biology and genetics.
Distribution of the test statistic bw for this setting : For a single X and Y cycle (i.e., c = d = 1), X set size k = 2 and Y set size q = 3, obtain the null probabilities under the assumption of perfect rankings for each of the 5! = 120 distinct possible permutations of the judgment ordered X and Y obs..
Create an alice world with six butterflies in the world : Create a generic random movement method that will use random numbers to pick a direction and an amount, and then cause a butterfly to move accordingly. d. Place the six butterflies in a list, and create methods and events to make all of the butter..
The horticulture research international-east manning : In 1997, scientists at the Horticulture Research International-East Manning conducted an exploratory study to assess the potential impact of RSS. The results of this investigation were reported in Murray, Ridout, and Cross (2000).

Reviews

Write a Review

Business Law and Ethics Questions & Answers

  Discussion of laws protecting consumers

discussion of laws protecting consumers as well as, for example, laws protecting the small business owner from other business's practices or from their suppliers and manufacturers

  Explain why not prosecuting the cases is the wrong public

Explain why not prosecuting the cases is the wrong public and social policy. Of course, you are also hopeful that the victim, Maureen, also receives help in her case

  Thoroughly discuss the organizational structure

Thoroughly discuss the organizational structure related to community policing. Compare decentralization in context with how the department deploys organizational resources.

  Describes how a vpn can be implemented

Compose a 2-3 page report to CEO Deese that describes how a VPN can be implemented and what security protocols are needed to protect the Nitro Hardware Company's digital information

  Buck drink company incbdc is a local business that sells

buck drink company inc.bdc is a local business that sells raging old cafinnated kola rock soft drinks. bdc decided to

  An american petroleum engineer

Question 2. 2. (TCO I) An American Petroleum Engineer, who has been on an Offshore Nigerian Oil Platform for 30 days, enters Lagos harbor in a work boat with 15 Nigerian oil rig workers. The work boat is stopped by the Lagos Harbor Police. The..

  How can we bring him back to the us

You have been asked to investigate the case. Please discuss the legal issues surrounding the case. Also, you have identified the individual involved. How can we bring him back to the U.S? Is it possible

  Describe the companys ethical obligation

Explain the situation of the event - Describe the company's ethical obligation in their communications to the public.

  Back in his office john quick gets to work john decides

back in his office john quick gets to work. john decides that his first priority is to find the funding for the

  Analyzes and explains the facts of the williams case

Analyzes and explains the facts in the Rose case. Describes the causes of wrongful conviction in the Rose case. Analyzes and explains the facts of the Williams case.

  Which interest groups and individuals are active on both

in the wake of the terrorist attacks in new york on september 11 2001 a law called the usa patriot act was passed by

  Paper on political and legal influences on robotic surgury

Write paper on Political and legal influences on Robotic Surgury

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd