Should supreme court uphold the appellate courts decision

Assignment Help Management Theories

Reference no: EM131378407

William Stevenson offered to help Rayford LeBlanc remove his truck from the mud. At first, LeBlanc refused.

However, later, when the towing company that LeBlanc had called proved to be unavailable, he accepted Stevenson's offer of assistance. LeBlanc then bought a towing strap from a nearby store to help in the removal of his truck from the mud. The first two attempts at removing the truck failed.

On the third attempt, while LeBlanc was still in the process of connecting the straps to his truck, Stevenson, apparently without warning, pulled his vehicle forward. This movement caught LeBlanc by surprise. His hand was still wrapped up in the strap, and therefore, as Stevenson's vehicle moved forward, LeBlanc's hand was severely injured. LeBlanc sued Stevenson for damages related to the injuries to his hand. The jury decided that Stevenson was not at fault, and LeBlanc found himself on the losing end of the lawsuit.

Accordingly, he appealed the case. The appellate court threw out the jury's factual finding and awarded LeBlanc over $190,000 in damages. Stevenson hollered "foul" and asked the Supreme Court of Louisiana to hear his request to have the decision reversed. The high court accepted the case.

One of the central issues involved the question of whether, and under what circumstances, an appellate court can overturn decisions of fact made by a jury. Should the supreme court uphold the appellate court's decision? What standard of review should be involved here? Explain.

LeBlanc v. Stevenson, 770 So.2d 766 (Sup. Ct. LA).

Reference no: EM131378407

Questions Cloud

Does given case belong in the us supreme court : Does this case belong in the U.S. Supreme Court? Explain the reasons for your response. Should the Supreme Court uphold or overturn the federal district court's decision? Explain.

How do businesses create a successful corporate culture : How do businesses create a successful corporate culture? If you're interested in exploring high employee motivation and loyalty, prepare a report on corporate culture. Corporate culture is the synthesis of an organization's collective beliefs, val..

Explain the social inequalities related to this social issue : This milestone is a concept map that will help you visualize the social issue and how it relates to the following sociological concepts: cultural beliefs and biases, social roles, social inequalities, and existing social conditions. A concept map ..

Is the government of sudan correct in given case : The argument was based on the fact that the case involved citizens of states of the United States in an attempt to sue a foreign government, something not permitted under federal law. Is the government of Sudan correct in this case? Explain.

Should supreme court uphold the appellate courts decision : Should the supreme court uphold the appellate court's decision? What standard of review should be involved here? Explain.

Discuss about the post given below : Jerome is a 28-year-old African American male who lives alone in an apartment. He tells everyone he meets that he is a rapper and a male model. He has business cards for each vocation. He has never recorded a song nor held any modeling job. He has..

What are the steps in a criminal prosecution : How is cyber-jurisdiction determined?- What is electronically stored information?- What are the steps in a criminal prosecution?

What is the difference between efficiency and effectiveness : What is the difference between efficiency and effectiveness? Are efficiency and effectiveness mutually exclusive? Can you be efficient at utilizing available resources, even though you may have discrimination against minority or female workers.

What is the structure of a typical state court systems : What is the structure of a typical state court systems?- What is civil litigation?- What are the most common discovery techniques?

User Account

All Pages