Should state y lower court have followed ruling of state x

Assignment Help Management Theories

Reference no: EM131377382

On June 15, a newspaper columnist predicted that the coast of State X would be flooded on the following September 1. Relying on this pronouncement, Gullible quit his job and sold his property at a loss so as not to be financially ruined. When the flooding did not occur, Gullible sued the columnist in a State X court for damages. The court dismissed the case for failure to state a cause of action under applicable state law. On appeal, the State X Supreme Court upheld the lower court. Three months after this ruling, the State Y Supreme Court heard an appeal in which a lower court had ruled that a reader could sue a columnist for falsely predicting flooding.

a. Must the State Y Supreme Court follow the ruling of the State X Supreme Court as a matter of stare decisis?

b. Should the State Y lower court have followed the ruling of the State X Supreme Court until the State Y Supreme Court issued a ruling on the issue?

c. Once the State X Supreme Court issued its ruling, could the U.S. Supreme Court overrule the State X Supreme Court?

d. If the State Y Supreme Court and the State X Supreme Court rule in exactly opposite ways, must the U.S. Supreme Court resolve the conflict between the two courts?

Reference no: EM131377382

Questions Cloud

How does water affect plant and animal growth : What is a genetic variation?How does water affect plant and animal growth?how does light effect plant and animal growth?

Should mary prevail and why : Later Peter returned with a search warrant and arrested Mary. Mary was charged with various narcotics law violations. Mary asserted the defense of entrapment. Should Mary prevail? Why?

Represent the surface stresses on a mohr circle : Represent the surface stresses on a Mohr circle of an internally pressurized section of round steel tubing that is subjected to tangential and axial stresses at the surface of 400 and 250 MPa, respectively. Superimposed on this is a torsional stre..

What difference between hospital and long term care facility : What are some of the obvious differences between a hospital and a long term care facility that will likely affect health information at this facility?

Should state y lower court have followed ruling of state x : Should the State Y lower court have followed the ruling of the State X Supreme Court until the State Y Supreme Court issued a ruling on the issue?

Draw the mohr circle representation of the state of stress : For a critical three-dimensional state of stress where, σx = 45,000, σy = 25,000, σz = -50,000, τxy = 4000, τyz = 2000, and τzx = -3500 psi, determine the principal stresses and draw the Mohr circle representation of the state of stress.

May professor rabelais challenge given law in state z courts : May Professor Rabelais challenge this law in State Z courts?- May Professor Rabelais challenge this law in a federal district court?

Profit maximizing price-quantity combination for monopolist : Suppose that firms’ marginal and average costs are constant and equal to c and that inverse market demand is given by P = a – bQ, where a,b>0. Calculate the profit maximizing price-quantity combination for a monopolist. Also calculate the monopolist’..

Obtain jurisdiction against diem for damages : Butt would like to know if he personally serves the proper papers to Diem whether he can obtain jurisdiction against Diem for damages in the given courts:

User Account

All Pages