Should she pursue the poison pill strategy

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM131055310

Case Study: Guilty or Not Guilty: Does It Matter?

Dr. Jennifer Bauer has been asked by the defense attorney to assist in jury selection. The defendant is a battered wife who has been accused of murdering her abusive husband one night when he was drunk and became verbally abusive.

The defense attorney has also hired a prominent psychiatrist who has suggested that the defense attorney use the battered woman syndrome as a defense strategy. Dr. Bauer thinks that this is a poor decision since the syndrome evidence has not been very successful in court cases, and she believes that the argument would be more successful using posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) as a defense. However, she was hired to assist in jury selection and not to help develop the defense strategy. Additionally, the psychiatrist retained by the attorney has developed a career arguing the syndrome evidence in courts and is not very receptive to criticism.

Dr. Bauer reads through the discovery materials, including the evidence provided by the defense and the prosecution. Despite her empathy for battered women, Dr. Bauer feels that the weak defense strategy along with the strong evidence against the defendant will lead to a guilty verdict for the defendant.

During the voir dire process, Dr. Bauer decides that many of the potential jurors are not sympathetic toward the defendant. She decides that the only possibility is to hope for a mistrial by employing the poison pill strategy. She hopes to select jurors whose strong personality differences make them clash so much during the deliberations that they are unable to come to a unanimous verdict.

Tasks:

In a minimum of 250 words, analyze the case study and address the following:

How should Dr. Bauer proceed? Provide reasons to support your answer.

Should she offer her advice regarding the syndrome evidence? Why or why not?

Should she pursue the poison pill strategy? Why or why not?

APA at least 1 intext citation

Reference no: EM131055310

Questions Cloud

Information about the statue of liberty : Use the information about the Statue of Liberty on page 88 to explain how equations are used to describe heights. Include an equation relating the heights of the Sears Tower, which is 1454 feet tall, the two antenna towers on top of the building, ..
Discuss some of the methodological issues unique : State the topic you selected and then write two potential research questions that could be explored on the topic you selected. Identify at least one potential research design to answer each of the research questions you wrote (you will identify a t..
What is the expected NPV of the new project : A firm is considering a new project that has a cost of $1,000. Suppose, the CFO asked you to set up the decision tree to show its three most likely scenarios. The best case scenario happens with probability of 0.2, and produces three cash flows of $8..
Required return on stock-what is the current share price : Apocalyptica Corporation is expected to pay the following dividends over the next four years: $6.90, $17.90, $22.90, and $4.70. Afterwards, the company pledges to maintain a constant 6.00 percent growth rate in dividends, forever. Required: If the re..
Should she pursue the poison pill strategy : How should Dr. Bauer proceed? Provide reasons to support your answer. Should she offer her advice regarding the syndrome evidence? Why or why not?
Prepare the amortization schedule for the loan : Bill has $25,000 in an investment account earning 6 percent per year. Bill decides to purchase a new car with a sticker price of $25,000. The car dealer offers Bill either $2,000 cash back or 2% financing for 5 years. Calculate the monthly payment re..
If the benchmark price-sales ratio for the company : TwitterMe, Inc., is a new company and currently has negative earnings. The company’s sales are $2,700,000 and there are 275,000 shares outstanding. If the benchmark price-sales ratio for the company is 5.3, how much will you pay for the stock? If the..
The managing editor of well-known business journal : Beverly Sutton is now employed as the managing editor of a well-known business journal. Although she thoroughly enjoys her job and the people she works with, wat she would really like to do is open a bookstore of her own. She would like to open her s..
Does monsanto maintain an ethical culture : Does Monsanto maintain an ethical culture that effectively responds to various stakeholdwes?

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Gastrointestinal disorders

Gastrointestinal Disorders

  Written in opposition to slavery

Both Sojourner Truth’s autobiographical Narrative and Harriet Beecher Stowe’s fictional Uncle Tom’s Cabin were written in opposition to slavery. Compare the passages of these two female authors and describe any similarities and/or differences you see..

  Describe the roles citizens as consumers play

Give at least two examples of the role that technology played and plays in both scenarios.  Based on the two experiences described above, describe the roles citizens as consumers play in a country's desire for a fast-growing and yet sufficiently sta..

  What is test purpose in relation to forensic setting or

what is a test purpose in relation to a forensic setting or a psychological test? define uses particularly in a

  Descriptions of the work environments

When reviewing the descriptions of the work environments, identify elements that appear to foster employee motivation and group cohesion among employees.

  Making risk-and quality management decisions

Which step in decision making process do you think is difficult to complete? What would you do to change or make it easier? Which information would you say is most overlooked when making risk-and quality management decisions?

  Ethnocentrism is generally defined

Ethnocentrism is generally defined as viewing one's own culture as superior to all others. However, quite often, it is not quite that obvious. Whenever we encounter something that seems strange or different, we will feel some degree of discomfort.

  Advantage of open-ended questions

Which of the following is not an advantage of open-ended questions?

  What conventions were used to create female characters

Discusses the exclusion of actual women from the theaters of the past and the conventions used to create female characters on stage. How were women represented on the stage? What conventions were used to create female characters

  Assume that you have just been appointed to a high level

suppose you have just been appointed to a high level position in the economic analysis unit of the state department.

  Nuclear reaction in a star''s core remain under control

The nuclear reaction in a star's core remain under control so long as?

  Judicial philosophy guide court''s exercise judicial review

What judicial philosophy should guide the Supreme Court's exercise of judicial review? Should the Supreme Court's power of judicial review be strictly limited by a constitutional amendment?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd