Should appellate court reverse decision of the lower court

Assignment Help Management Theories

Reference no: EM131378666

The Borg-Warner Protective Services Corporation and Burns International Security Services contracted to provide security for the Cleveland Institute of Art (CIA). Robert Adelman was struck by an object thrown by a CIA student from the roof of one of the Institute's buildings. Adelman sued both the CIA and the security corporations.

The security corporations moved for summary judgment, arguing that they had contracted with CIA to protect the faculty and the students and that they therefore had no duty to protect pedestrians outside the buildings. Adelman argued that the contract specifically obligated the security corporations to control the activities of CIA students within the Institute's buildings. The disputed clause read that the security corporations agreed "to control the movement and activities of students within the buildings at all hours."

The trial court granted the summary judgment motion, and Adelman appealed. Should the appellate court reverse the decision of the lower court? Explain. If the case goes to trial, how will the court determine the meaning of the ambiguous clause? Explain.

Adelman v. Timman, 690 N.E.2d 1332.

Reference no: EM131378666

Questions Cloud

How did the supreme court decide the case : Several businesspeople secured a contract with the state of Massachusetts that permitted them to construct a bridge spanning the Charles River.- . How did the Supreme Court decide the case? Explain.

Did rockefeller raise or lower price of oil for consumer : Did Rockefeller raise or lower the price of oil for consumers? Did he increase or decrease access to oil? What impact did this change have on the living experience of consumers? In particular, were wealthy consumers or poor consumers impacted more?

What is indirect utility function : What is indirect utility function? How will you derive an indirect utility fuctio from a direct utility function?ezplain roy''s identity?

Use economics to evaluate such policies : Both Trump and Clinton campaigned on the promise of reducing the amount of foreign products sold in America. Use economics to evaluate such policies. Who would benefit the most? Who would be hurt the most? In light of this analysis, but according to ..

Should appellate court reverse decision of the lower court : The trial court granted the summary judgment motion, and Adelman appealed. Should the appellate court reverse the decision of the lower court? Explain. If the case goes to trial, how will the court determine the meaning of the ambiguous clause? Ex..

The annual operating cost is expected to be constant : An asset with a first cost of $250,000 is expected to have a maximum useful life of 10 years and a market value that decreases $25,000 each year. The annual operating cost is expected to be constant at $25,000 per year for 5 years and to increase at ..

How project integration management relates to portfolio : Explain how Project Integration Management relates to project portfolio management. Provide examples of the above in the context of specific projects.

Could stewart sue the bank for not cashing the check : Nevertheless, the bank refused to cash the check for Stewart, even though there was enough money in the account to cover the $185.48. Could Stewart sue the bank for not cashing the check as he requested? Explain.

What was the significance of the mongol invasion : Can you please write 2-3 paper on this topic and thank you for your help Discuss the rise to power and expansion of the Mongol Empire. What was the significance of the Mongol invasion and occupation for Asian History

User Account

All Pages