Should a physician be responsible for informing patients

Reference no: EM132905152

A woman in her mid-thirties suffered from a rare malignancy in her brain and around her spinal cord. She had surgery, and most of the tumor mass was removed, but the residual tumor remained in the brain and around the spinal cord. The doctors informed her that chemotherapy and radiation were possible treatment options but could cause serious problems such as sepsis, a permanent loss of IQ and stature, and even death. She wished to proceed with the therapy.

After undergoing aggressive chemotherapy and radiation, she did independent research and read of several drugs being administered for cancer in other states that were unapproved by the Federal Drug Administration (FDA) and were illegal in their home state but were touted by physicians using them as "miracle cures." The woman is considering suing her physician for failure to disclose alternative treatments, thus depriving her of informed consent.
A court awarded summary judgment to the physician.

Respond to the following questions about this case:

Question 1: In your opinion, does the court's decision seem warranted? Why or why not?

Question 2: Under the doctrine of informed consent, should a physician be responsible for informing patients of all treatment options, even if some of the treatments are illegal or not yet proven effective? Explain your answer.

Reference no: EM132905152

Questions Cloud

What is the purpose of pre-authorisation : 1. Why it is required to complete the guest registration process upon guest check-in?

Discuss the current disease process at the cellular level : Discuss the current disease process at the cellular level (in your own words). Explain why this patient is encountering this particular health deficit.

Hospital has been accessing patient records : You have been assigned to investigate whether or not an employee at a local hospital has been accessing patient records

How might target questions for building a health history : What risk assessment instruments would be appropriate to use with each patient, or what questions would you ask each patient to assess his or her health risks?

Should a physician be responsible for informing patients : Should a physician be responsible for informing patients of all treatment options, even if some of the treatments are illegal or not yet proven effective?

How will administer the learning needs assessment to student : Explanation of data collection techniques such as the format and how you will administer the learning needs assessment to your students.

Managerial issues of networked organization : Research at least two articles on the topic of managerial issues of a networked organization.

Business continuity planning is process : Business continuity planning (BCP) is the process involved in creating a system of prevention and recovery from potential threats to a company.

Identify a potential problem that would like to investigate : Identify a potential problem (topic) that you would like to investigate through nursing research. Begin by reading the American Association of Colleges

User Account

All Pages