Schools of legal interpretation

Assignment Help Operation Management
Reference no: EM131398990

Schools of legal interpretation.

When asked to apply the law, judges are often required to interpret the meaning or purpose of the law to give it the effect intended by the legislature when it was passed. This is especially important in cases where the facts of the case require the court to apply laws that may be conflicting and the court must balance the competing interests and choose the right one. For the following legal conflicts, identify which of the six schools of thought would help the Court reach the best decision:

a. Judge asked to recognize a gay partner s status as a surviving spouse, even though state law does not recognize same-sex marriage. State which school of thought would allow the judge to recognize a same-sex partner as a surviving spouse, define that school of thought and explain why it applies to this set of facts. Also state, define, and explain which school of thought would not allow the judge to recognize a same-sex partner as a surviving spouse.

Judge rules for Ohio same sex couple

b. Judge asked to decide a death penalty case, even though he is personally opposed to the death penalty as contrary to his religious beliefs. State which school of thought would cause the judge to apply the death penalty, define that school of thought, and explain why it applies to this set of facts. Also, state, define and explain which school of thought would cause the judge to set aside the death penalty because of strong personal beliefs.

Montgomery County Common Pleas Judge A. J. Wagner has asked to be excused from the case of Cody Henderson, 20, indicted on three counts of aggravated murder.

c. Judge asked to determine if prosecutors can refuse to enforce immigration laws against minor offenders. (This article is about adults who committed minor criminal offenses, and not minor children. The prosecutors want to focus on serious criminal offenders.)

Judge: Obama administration can't refuse to arrest illegal immigrants.

Reference no: EM131398990

Questions Cloud

Direct contact with customers if a firm is in direct contact : Direct contact with customers If a firm is in direct contact with its customers, it is more aware of changes in customer attitudes. It is in a better position to adjust its marketing mix quickly because there is no need to convince other channel memb..
The internet makes direct distribution easier website : The Internet makes direct distribution easier Website-based e-commerce systems and delivery services like UPS and FedEx give many firms direct access to customers whom it would have been impossible to reach in the past. Even small, specialized firms ..
Define precedent and stare decisis : Define precedent and stare decisis. Explain how precedent and stare decisis will help a trial court judge decide an issue they are facing. If you were a business owner, how would having knowledge of case law relevant to your business help guide your ..
Organizational factors such as morale-culture-motivation : Why are managerial writing skills so important to organizational factors such as morale, culture, motivation, and collaboration?
Schools of legal interpretation : When asked to apply the law, judges are often required to interpret the meaning or purpose of the law to give it the effect intended by the legislature when it was passed. This is especially important in cases where the facts of the case require the ..
When companies have close competitors : When companies have close competitors, they try to choose value propositions that will differentiate them from others in the market. Choose three fast-food restaurants and describe their value propositions. Are they strongly differentiating themselve..
Different techniques aligned with social responsibility : Do you think decision making could be improved by altering how existing techniques are used, or by implementing different techniques aligned with social responsibility? Why? Do you think it is important to alter decision-making techniques based on et..
Indicate whether the variable is categorical or quantitative : For each of the following characteristics of an individual, indicate whether the variable is categorical or quantitative.- Length of forearm from elbow to wrist (in centimeters).- Whether or not the person has ever been the victim of a crime.
Indicate whether the variable is ordinal or not : For each of the given, indicate whether the variable is ordinal or not. If the variable is not ordinal, indicate its variable type.

Reviews

Write a Review

Operation Management Questions & Answers

  Upper-level management might recommend cost reductions

Jordan Baker is the Senior Accountant for Archer Manufacturing and is concerned that the company’s net income may be lower than expected this year. If it is, he is afraid that upper-level management might recommend cost reductions by reducing the num..

  Discuss the importance of the authenticity of a leader

Discuss the importance of the authenticity of a leader. Why are morality, social responsibility and ethics necessary for an authentic and effective leader? Give examples to illustrate your thoughts.

  Organizational behavior movement toward team utilization

What strengths are associated with your organizational behavior movement toward team utilization? When would you implement work teams? When would you encourage individual contribution in lieu of teams?

  Summer place property

Charles and Mary Gunderson owned a house at 532 Summer Place, N.Y. (the Summer Place property) as tenants by the entirety. They had three children: Barbara Gillis, Joan Wallen, and Martha Washington. When Mary Gunderson died in 1984, Charles became t..

  International-multinational-global or transnational

Imagine you were the CEO of a major company. What approach to global competition would you choose for your firm: international, multinational, global, or transnational? Why?

  What is the present value of the bonds

What is the present value of the bonds? ( Round amount to the nearest cent)

  How effective are the measurement guidelines

What measurement guidelines is each company using to verify its strategic effectiveness? How effective are the measurement guidelines that each company is using?

  One of the follower characteristics in path-goal theory

One of the follower characteristics in path-goal theory is perception of ability. As perception of ability goes up, directive leadership should go down. Why is this? And what is the effect on the follower if directive leadership continues to be used?

  Define what happens to the ordering and holding costs

For each scenario in the below table, run 30 simulations and report the overall mean service level and the estimated total cost. Does this new reorder point achieve the desired service level of .9? If so, which scenario would you recommend

  Making any laws with respect to establishment of religion

The First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution prohibits Congress from making any laws with respect to the establishment of religion or that interfere with the free exercise of religion. It is generally agreed that the provisions of the First Amendment..

  Who determines what is objectionable or offensive

According to Shaw and Barry, in answering the question "In the case of sexual harassment, who determines what is objectionable or offensive." the courts have asked what the reasonable woman would find offensive. However there are a number of peopl..

  Considering the possibility of operating small business

You are considering the possibility of operating a small business or practice in some activity related to health care, as either a provider of some kind of care or as a service intended to support various provider organizations in their care-delivery..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd