Response the given case using irac method

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics
Reference no: EM131104076

Jim lives in Detroit, MI. One day, Jim is at a local bar. He has had a few drinks, but he is not intoxicated. As he is about to leave, he asks the bartender for a cup of water. The bartender by mistake, hands him a 6 ounce cup to 40% Vodka instead. Jim gulps down the glass quickly. Henotices the strength of the liquid, but figures that it must be his imagination; as he clearly asked for water. Jim gets in his car and drives home.

Unfortunately for him, the vodka goes straight to his head and he becomes intoxicated. Because of Jim's inoxication, he loses control of his car, which jumps a curb and kills 2 people. Jim is arrested and put on trial under Michigan's "causing death while operating a motor vehicle while intoxicated" statute, which carries a penalty of up to 15 years in prison.

Jim wants to argue that he did not knowingly drink enough to make him drunk. However, the judge instructs the jury that whether Jim knew that the liquid that he drank was vodka was irrelevant because driving while intoxicated is a strict liability offense. Jim's attorney claims that this would be unconstitutional because it would not be fair to give somebody such a severe punishment without proving any mensrea on Jim's part.

Who is correct? Please use appropriate case law to support your answer. An IRAC-based essay is appropriate for this assignment.

Reference no: EM131104076

Questions Cloud

Which of the above is true why : Explain the human-capital view of education and the signaling view of education.
Explore thomas paine theory : IMPORTANT TO READ: Your essay needs to adhere to the following format: 4-5 pgs., 12pt. font, double-spaced with 1in. margins. Citation of reading should follow MLA format. Pick ONE of the following Prompts to write your essay.
Find the formula of income-consumption curve : 1. Chloe consumes chicken wing (x) and beer (y). Let Px+Py=M be Chloe's budget constraint and her utility function is U(x, y)=5xy. a. Find the formula of income-consumption curve. (This is nothing new. You have solved this many times before.)
Prepare a statement of cash flows for odgers inc : Prepare a statement of cash flows using the indirect method and Compute the following ratios for 2014 - Prepare a statement of cash flows for Odgers Inc. using the direct method.
Response the given case using irac method : Jim's attorney claims that this would be unconstitutional because it would not be fair to give somebody such a severe punishment without proving any mensrea on Jim's part. Who is correct? Please use appropriate case law to support your answer.
Channels of monetary policy transmission : What are some of the conditions for effectiveness of the bank credit channels of monetary policy transmission? List at least two and explain why they are necessary.
A neutral effect on the spread value : Consider a riskless spread with a long position in the August 160 call and a short position in the October 160 call. Determine the appropriate hedge ratio.
Question regarding the ricardian equivalence : What does the concept of "Ricardian equivalence" refer to? What are the conditions for the Ricardian equivalence to hold? Does it hold in practice?
Following net cash flows and abandonment values : 1. A small high-speed commercial centrifuge has the following net cash flows and abandonment values over its useful life (see Table P9-15, p. 439).

Reviews

Write a Review

Business Law and Ethics Questions & Answers

  The major trait of corporate identity

Question1: "The major trait of corporate identity is that organization is a legitimate substance unmistakable from the individuals.'' Elucidate the announcement. Likewise indicate the imperative components of an organization.

  Component of the law enforcement system

Present national juvenile data and trends based on the FBI - Uniform Crime Reports and the Bureau of Justice Statistics - Crime Type, or other comparable nationally recognized data bases, such as the U.S. Department of Education data on campus cri..

  New south wales operations manager of computers

For the past five years Chu has been the New South Wales Operations Manager of Computers Pty Ltd, a company which retails computer software and hardware. Because of his senior position, Chu knows the identity and requirements of the company's major c..

  What is the current status of right-to-work laws

What is the current status of right-to-work laws? Which of the following statutes regulates internal union affairs and establishes certain rights of union members

  Discuss at least three significant cases related to three

write a 1400- to 1750-word paper in which you discuss at least three significant cases related to three of the

  Describe how these three branches are supposed to interact

What are the duties and responsibilities of each branch of the federal government? Describe how these three branches are supposed to interact. How effectively do you feel the three branches interact with each other today

  Review a holiday package from a brochure

You work for an advertising company and are asked to review a holiday package from a brochure before it goes to print. You are asked to provide advice to the advertising company on the legal effect of the representations in the brochure. You are a..

  Free trade of the americas conference analysis

Write paper on Free Trade of the Americas Conference Analysis

  Outline of the case law covering brady claims and jencks act

As a Defense Attorney, you are required to disclose certain information prior to trial. Prepare a 3 page outline of the Case Law covering Brady claims and the Jencks Act

  Documentation of what you do is extremely important you

research current events related to the course topics covered in units 1 - 4 and post at least 2 of these events to the

  What operations and processes are we looking for

1250 word and there is a data which I will send it to you to apply on the case studies And for the cases explain each of them and apply the data then chose one and focus on it just recommend one case of the three Find the

  Explain how laws or regulations affect your present job

Discuss the concept of judicial review. Explain how laws or regulations affect your present job or industry

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd