Rail versus pipeline investment

Assignment Help Operation Management

Reference no: EM132206145

Rail Versus Pipeline Investment

The last several years has seen a tremendous growth in rail shipments into and out of North Dakota and southern Canada. These shipments were oil outbound and water, sand, and other operating materials inbound. This growth was caused by OPEC’s decision to hold steady their oil production volumes, which made U.S. fracking and oil well development in those two areas very profitable. This growth in rail shipments was also caused by the lack of oil and gas pipeline capacity outbound from those two areas to U.S. processing plants. In fact, the growth in volume was so high that the railroads serving those areas ran out of both car and track capacity. With volumes increasing at a steady rate, the obvious solution would be for the railroads to build more track and acquire more operating equipment. However, investments in equipment and track are long-term, with equipment and track lasting decades with proper care. As such, these types of investments require a steady volume over their life. The railroads serving these areas were faced with a difficult decision. To adequately meet demand would require billions of dollars of capital investment but, short term, could produce billions of dollars in additional revenue. However, the railroads were cautious of OPEC’s influence on the price of oil. OPEC had announced that its members would be increasing the production of crude, thus driving down the world price. With the small oil and gas operators in North Dakota and Southern Canada having a much higher marginal operating cost than the OPEC countries, a declining world price for crude could force many of them to leave the industry. The negative impact of these exits could be substantial for the railroads.

CASE QUESTIONS

1. If you were president of one of these railroads, what decision would you make? Maintain current capacity and forgo additional revenue? Make the investment in additional capacity with the assumption that volume will continue to increase? Explain your answer.

2. Could there be a shorter term solution for the railroads other than acquiring more equipment and building more track that would allow them to generate revenue without making significant investments?

Reference no: EM132206145

Questions Cloud

Emergence of supply management as valued business function : What role do the five M’s play in the emergence of supply management as a valued business function?

Discuss the role which the human resources function : Discuss the role which the human resources function should play in the development and implementation of organizational strategy.

Explain two ways to track and report content metrics : Briefly list and explain two ways to track and report content metrics.

Explain each quantitative metric listed as common metric : Briefly list and explain each quantitative metric listed as a common metric.

Rail versus pipeline investment : The last several years has seen a tremendous growth in rail shipments into and out of North Dakota and southern Canada.

Strategic planning is considered the steps organization : Strategic Planning is considered the steps an organization uses to determine the direction or vision of the company.

Hierarchical planning process useful for project planning : Why is the hierarchical planning process useful for project planning? How might it influence the plan if the hierarchical planning process was not used?

Some businesses resist discussing social responsibility : Some businesses resist discussing social responsibility because people believe that business profitability creates social problems.

Whose actions could have unfortunate legal ramifications : Helen’s colleague regularly takes credit for work that others in the department have completed. Whose actions could have unfortunate legal ramifications?

User Account

All Pages