Provide an example of a two-wrongs-make-a-right fallacy

Reference no: EM133612504

Problem

Dissue, but they should also know how to identify and address fallacies that undermine the problem-solving process.

Before completing this discussion, review the "Fallacies of Relevance" section in Ch. 11, "Reasoning Critically," of Thinking Critically.

Scenario

You are a shift supervisor in a correctional facility. A person who is incarcerated at the correctional facility alleges they are being bullied by other people who are incarcerated at the correctional facility, and that a correctional officer you supervise has been permitting that to happen. After some investigation, you have determined the allegation is valid and are conducting an interview with the correctional officer. The correctional officer is providing you with fallacies of relevance in an attempt to control the interview and your findings.

1. Provide an example of a two-wrongs-make-a-right fallacy of relevance argument that the correctional officer may make during the interview. How would you respond in order to focus the interview on the information you are seeking?

2. Provide 1 example of a red herring fallacy of relevance argument that the correctional officer may make during the interview. How would you respond in order to focus the interview on the information you are seeking?

Reference no: EM133612504

Questions Cloud

Which one is the best method for this problem : region has been inhabited for thousands of years by Native Americans and for hundreds by European and African immigrants

Prepare a summary of four potential employment opportunities : prepare a summary of four potential employment opportunities, qualification including education and earning in career that are best aligned with their interest.

Discussion your own original ideas : Discussion posts which are generic, vague, do not provide original insight, or are missing references will result in a reduction of points

What are john potential claims if he is terminated : Read the hypothetical scenario below. What are John's potential claims if he is terminated this week?

Provide an example of a two-wrongs-make-a-right fallacy : Provide an example of a two-wrongs-make-a-right fallacy of relevance argument that the correctional officer may make during the interview.

What is the perspective of greene regarding the purpose : What is the perspective of Greene regarding the purpose of woman-marriage, and how does she explain it using descent theory and alliance theory

Does fourth amendment exclusionary rule apply to evidence : Does the Fourth Amendment exclusionary rule apply to evidence obtained by police who rely on a statute authorizing warrantless administrative searches?

What are some roles of religion in cultures : What are some roles of religion in cultures? Also, religions and religious organizations, such as churches, synagogues, or mosques and the like, serve various

Was supreme court correct in application of vavilov standard : Is this judgment is a "step forward to raise the threshold of what constitutes a threat to national security?

User Account

All Pages