Proof of a diminished mental capacity

Reference no: EM133302181

Question: LIGHT OF the arguments raised by Prof. Sanford Kadish, and by Professors Thomas Nagel, Michael Davis, and David Lewis, you are asked (1) first, to indicate the reasons why, in your judgment, our hero Ethan Hawley, the protagonist and narrator of Steinbeck's classic The Winter of our Discontent (1961) is deserving of criminal punishment for his attempt to rob a bank, and (2) second, to indicate the reasons why, in your judgment, Ethan is deserving of a substantially lesser penalty simply because, at the final instant before carrying out his carefully laid plan. For example, and how, might his defense counsel raise an affirmative defense of temporary insanity, or perhaps mitigate the penalty by offering proof of a diminished mental capacity? Some might belief that he deserves no punishment after all, but in that event, they are obliged to clearly state their reasons.

Reference no: EM133302181

Questions Cloud

Write a letter to ms hornung to give her the bad news : Write to Ms. Hornung to give her the bad news. See if you can figure out how to keep her goodwill and her future business.write a letter using block format

Discuss the causes and pathogenesis of vertigo : Discuss the causes of deafness. Discuss the causes and pathogenesis of vertigo.

Explain the problem and use the terms principle : how we can find motivation to follow the rules beyond "because I said so." Explain the problem and use the terms principle of utility and sanction

Differences do you think are more salient : What cultural differences do you think are more salient in causing misunderstanding? Explain why. Have you experienced misunderstanding

Proof of a diminished mental capacity : Proof of a diminished mental capacity? Some might belief that he deserves no punishment after all, but in that event, they are obliged to clearly state

Eu competition policy impact on us technology giants : How do developments in EU Competition Policy impact on US technology giants?

What is an effective strategy when writing an introduction : Which of the following is an effective strategy to use when writing an introduction?Ending the paragraph with a bridging statement.

Narrative to the effect that users should stay in facebook : ILS 200 University of Wisconsin, Provide a narrative to the effect that users should stay in Facebook Provide a narrative to the effect that users should not

Explain what is wrong with the opposing answer : State your answer concerning what should happen or what is the right policy in the first sentence -State an opposing answer and the reason one would appeal

User Account

All Pages