Reference no: EM13859988
Instructions:
In the third unit we have discussed the controversy around the publication in the 1990s of Charles Murray's and Richard Hernstein's The Bell Curve and the various responses from specialists in the field of psychology, mental tests and even evolution that try to prove the problems with how we interpret the correlations between "IQ", "Intelligence", "Race" and various other social factors, among them "Social Class (or Social Economical Status)", "Profession" and "Education (or the very limited concept of "Schooling"). Taking this into consideration discuss why many specialists question these correlations and determinisms, specially how the differences of intelligence and social economic status can be solely explained though the concepts of "IQ" (or the "g" factor) and "Race" (assumed as a biological, pre-determined and culture free construct).
It is advisable that you take into account the following "guidelines" when elaborating your discussion:
1. How Neisser's task force report (composed of specialists in the field from the APA) or other groups efforts by other psychologists (among them Nisbet, Sternberg or even the paleontologist Stephen Jay Gould), have shown how these correlations are problematic, discussing that in reality we can't think of biology (or of genes) without taking into consideration the influence of the environment. Give at least two examples from these texts that show that "IQ" and "Race" cannot be assumed as fixed, exhaustive and causal factors that explain the inequalities of education, social-economic status or others social factors.
2. The political effects of The Bell Curve's thesis and conclusions, that in many ways justify (be it directly or indirectly) racially biased and extremely limited explanations regarding the role and importance of education and any kind of social and environmental reform.
3. Some, like Gould, would argue that these theses and conclusions (from The Bell Curve are a continuation (or a sort of "resurrection") of old forms of racism. In this sense, the problem is not only the validity of "IQ" as an exhaustive measure of "Intelligence" or of the "g" factor as an inherited and fixed measure of "Intelligence", but the validity of "Race" as a fixed and biological construct. Various specialist, among them Gould and Sternberg, will argue that, in reality, our uses of the concept of "Race" as a biological construct are problematic and in many way pseudo-scientific.
4. Use at least two (2) of the assigned texts. Limit yourself to said texts and the discussion in class.
Assigned texts (in the order they were assigned).
Neisser, U. et al (1996). Intelligence: Knowns and Unknowns. American Psychologist 51 (2): 77-101.
Nisbet, R. et al (2012). Intelligence: New Findings and Theoretical Developments. American Psychologists 67 (2): 130-159.
Fenwick, L.T. (1995). A History of the Constructs of IQ and Race: Putting "The Bell Curve" in Perspective. Paper Presented at the Annual Book Review (February, 1995): 3-17.
Sternberg, R., Grigorenko, E. & Kidd, K. (2005). Intelligence, Race, and Genetics. American Psychologist 60 (1): 46-59.
Gould, S.J. (1995). Ghost of Bell Curves Past. Natural History 2: 12-19
Gould, S.J. (1996). Alfred Binet and the original purposes of the Binet Scale. In Stephen Jay Gould, The Mismeasure of Man (176-188). New York: W.W. Norton
Gould, S.J. (1996). H.H. Goddard and the menace of the feeble-minded. In Stephen Jay Gould, The Mismeasure of Man (188-204). New York: W.W. Norton
|
Write down the set of strategy combinations
: Namely, the husband is unhappiest when he is at the opera by himself, he is a little happier when he is with his wife at the opera, he is happier still when he is at the football game by himself, and he is the happiest if they are both at the footbal..
|
|
Shortcomings of real gdp from a welfare perspective
: What are the some of the shortcomings of real GDP from a welfare perspective? do you have any practical suggestions for revising the computation of GDP to achieve a better measure of welfare?
|
|
Views of gdp from the perspectives of expenditure
: We discussed alternative views of GDP from the perspectives of expenditure, income and production. What are the basic differences in these approaches? why do they add to the same total for GDP?
|
|
Power is fundamental in international relations
: The concept of balance of power is fundamental in international relations. What does it mean? How meaningful can it be at the beginning of the 21st century, given the impact of globalization and modern warfare in which one's opponents may not be atta..
|
|
Political effects of the bell curve thesis and conclusions
: The political effects of The Bell Curve's thesis and conclusions, that in many ways justify (be it directly or indirectly) racially biased and extremely limited explanations regarding the role and importance of education and any kind of social and..
|
|
Production functions exhibit increasing
: State whether the following production functions exhibit increasing, constant, or decreasing returns to scale in K and L.
|
|
Shaped international relations
: What are three key events of the twentieth century that have shaped international relations today? Describe the events you choose and explain each of your choices.
|
|
Concept of balance of power is fundamental
: The concept of balance of power is fundamental in international relations. What does it mean? How meaningful can it be at the beginning of the 21st century, given the impact of globalization and modern warfare in which one's opponents may not be atta..
|
|
Explain how sellers costs-producer surplus and supply curve
: Explain how buyers’ willingness to pay, consumer surplus, and the demand curve are related. Explain how sellers' costs, producer surplus, and the supply curve are related.
|