Philosophy work based problems

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM13762293

Response Paper Instructions
Having completed the unit of philosophy of religion, you are now ready to respond to an article written by an actual atheist. This article titled "On Being an Atheist," was written by H. J. McCloskey in 1968 for the journal Question. McCloskey is an Australian philosopher who wrote a number of atheistic works in the 1960s and 70s including the book God and Evil (Nijhoff, 1974). In this article, McCloskey is both critical of the classical arguments for God's existence and offers the problem of evil as a reason why one should not believe in God. Please note the following parameters for this paper:

1. Your assignment is to read McCloskey's short article found in the Reading & Study folder in Module and respond to each of the questions below. Your instructor is looking for a detailed response to each question.

2. The response paper is to be a minimum of 1,500 words (not including quotes) and should be written as a single essay and not just a list of answers to questions.

3. The basis for your answers should primarily come from the resources provided in the lessons covering the philosophy of religion unit of the course (Evansand Manis, Craig, and the presentation) and these sources should be mentioned in your paper. You are not merely to quote these sources as an answer to the question-answer them in your own words.

4. You may use other outside sources as well, as long as you properly document them. However, outside sources are not necessary. Each of the questions can be answered from the sources provided in the lessons.

5. While the use of the Bible is not restricted, its use is not necessary and is discouraged unless you intend to explain the context of the passage and how that context applies to the issue at hand in accordance with the guidelines provided earlier in the course. You are not to merely quote scripture passages as answers to the questions. Remember this is a philosophical essay not a biblical or theological essay.

6. While you may quote from sources, all quotations should be properly cited and quotes from sources will not count towards the 1,500 word count of the paper.

7. You may be critical of McCloskey, but should remain respectful. Any disparaging comment(s)about McCloskey will result in a significant reduction in grade.

Specifically, you should address the following questions in your paper:

1. McCloskey refers to the arguments as "proofs" and often implies that they can't definitively establish the case for God, so therefore they should be abandoned. What would you say about this in light of Foreman's comments in his "Approaching the Question of God's Existence" presentation?

2. On the Cosmological Argument:
a. McCloskey claims that the "mere existence of the world constitutes no reason for believing in such a being [i.e., a necessarily existing being]." Using Evans and Manis' discussion of the non-temporal form of the argument (on pp. 69-77), explain why the cause of the universe must be necessary (and therefore uncaused).

b. McCloskey also claims that the cosmological argument "does not entitle us to postulate an all-powerful, all-perfect, uncaused cause." In light of Evans and Manis' final paragraph on the cosmological argument, how might you respond to McCloskey?

3. On the Teleological Argument:

a. McCloskey claims that "to get the proof going, genuine indisputable examples of design and purpose are needed." Discuss this standard of "indisputability" which he calls a "very conclusive objection." Is it reasonable?

b. From your reading in Evans and Manis, can you offer an example of design that, while not necessarily "indisputable," you believe provides strong evidence of a designer of the universe?

c. McCloskey implies that evolution has displaced the need for a designer. Assuming evolution is true, for argument's sake, how would you respond to McCloskey (see Evans and Manis pp. 82-83)?

d. McCloskey claims that the presence of imperfection and evil in the world argues against "the perfection of the divine design or divine purpose in the world." Remembering Evans and Manis' comments about the limitations of the cosmological argument, how might you respond to this charge by McCloskey?

4. On the Problem of Evil:

a. McCloskey's main objection to theism is the presence of evil in the world and he raises it several times: "No being who was perfect could have created a world in which there was avoidable suffering or in which his creatures would (and in fact could have been created so as not to) engage in morally evil acts, acts which very often result in injury to innocent persons." The language of this claim seems to imply that it is an example of the logical form of the problem. Given this implication and using Evans and Manis' discussion of the logical problem (pp. 159-168, noting especially his concluding paragraphs to this section), how might you respond to McCloskey?

b. McCloskey specifically discusses the free will argument, asking "might not God have very easily so have arranged the world and biased man to virtue that men always freely chose what is right?" From what you have already learned about free will in the course, and what Evans and Manis says about the free will theodicy, especially the section on Mackie and Plantinga'sresponse (pp. 163-166) and what he says about the evidential problem (pp. 168-172), how would you respond to McCloskey's question?

5. On Atheism as Comforting:

a.In the final pages of McCloskey's article, he claims that atheism is more comforting than theism. Using the argument presented by William Lane Craig in the article "The Absurdity of Life without God," (located in Reading & Study for Module/Week 6),respond to McCloskey's claim.

Reference no: EM13762293

Questions Cloud

Dss projects : DSS projects succeed more often than they fail or are challenged.
Show what the effect would be in the short run : Classify each of the following as a supply or demand shock. Use a graph to show the effects on inflation and output in the short run and the long run - show what the effect would be in the short run. Describe the effects on inflation and output.
Banks and the federal reserve system : Take a position on whether federal regulation helps or hurts U.S. banks. Provide support for your position.
Write an essay about language barriers : Write an essay about language barriers.
Philosophy work based problems : Discuss this standard of "indisputability" which he calls a "very conclusive objection.
Building successful information systems : Building successful information systems, Management support systems
Client demographics: for individual clients : Client demographics: For individual clients, you should include the client's name, age, marital status, occupation, and relevant family information (such as children or involved siblings or parents). If your client is an agency or organization,
What is the role of the narrator and the omniscient narrator : How do setting, description, and plot contribute to theme? How is character developed? What is the role of the narrator and the omniscient narrator?
Description of assignment : 1. Research and report on a controversial topic in the field of infant and toddler development. Find two academic articles (not websites or popular publications), published after 2005, that take opposing views on this topic. 2. Describe the issue, a..

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Earth science labin what order do materials settle in water

earth science labin what order do materials settle in water? so this is my topic in what order do materials settle in

  Why is leadership naturally persuasive

Why is leadership naturally persuasive? Give examples of instances when leadership has been persuasive. When have you been persuaded by leaders?

  Measures stress-executives have a dangerous level of stress

A researcher is using a questionnaire that measures stress. The questionnaire has been vallidated through past use. A score above 80 indicates stress at a dangerous level. A random sample of 15 executives revealed the following stress level scores. 9..

  Personality psychology and social psychology

Compare and contrast the following:Physiological Psychology, Personality Psychology and Social Psychology

  Researched position paper-war inevitable and integral

Growing up playing video games that were often centered on war, I developed an early interest in the concept of physical conflict. Slowly, my obsession with virtual war grew into a passion for reading war novels and watching war movies.

  What is a meaningful life

What do you think is the main feature of a good life? Do you think a good life must be measured on daily basis, or at the end of your life? What difference would this make?

  Legal effects of an annul

Explain the difference between the legal effects of an annulment of a marriage and the dissolution of a marriage.

  In their theological concern for the natural world

In their theological concern for the natural world, which medieval thinker are the Reformers closer to: Aquinas, Bonaventure, or Francis? Defend your answer with reference to both the center and the circumference of reformation thought.

  What ethical perspectives or lenses did you use to make

write a 700- to 1050- word reflective journal in which you address the following middot paper answers the following

  Review of new sources of air pollution

Compare and contrast how treatment and regulation of existing air pollution sources differ from that of a review of new sources of air pollution.

  Explain the effect of one it implementation

Explain the effect of one IT implementation that has a positive contribution on organizational behavior

  Healthcare spending and services

Healthcare data at a community, county, or region level and state level determine healthcare spending and services allocated for individuals. Using the South University Online Library or the Internet, research about these data as it will help you bui..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd