Part of a medical experiment

Reference no: EM13799252

Second Writing Assignment

In 1964, patients at a hospital in New York were injected by doctors with live cancer cells as part of a medical experiment. The patients were not told the true nature of the injections they were receiving; instead they were told that the injections were part of their treatment for whatever medical problem had originally brought them to the hospital. The patients were not in any danger from the injections. (You are to assume this.) There was no chance that the cancer cells would take root in their bodies and grow. The doctors simply wanted to measure the rate at which the human body would reject live cancer cells. The doctors explained that they kept the true nature of the injections secret from the patients because they thought they could gain valuable knowledge from the experiment-knowledge that might play a role in finding a cure for cancer-and they didn't think that anyone would consent to the injections if he or she knew that the injections contained cancer cells. Explain how an (a.) act utilitarian, (b.) a rule utilitarian (also known as a "rule consequentialist" for the purposes of this paper), and (c.) a Kantian would reason about the rightness or wrongness of what the doctors did. Explain what factors each one would take into consideration in his or her reasoning, and describe what conclusion you think each would be likely to arrive at. Be sure that your answer to this question is written in such a way that somebody who hadn't attended our class or done the course readings would grasp the basic idea of each of the above-mentioned philosophical positions.

(Note: Kant has two tests for the rightness of actions. One is covered in chapter 11 of the Shafer-Landau book; the other is covered in chapter 12. In discussing how a Kantian would reason about the above case, you should consider both tests.)

Reference no: EM13799252

Questions Cloud

The internal rate of return irr of a capital investment : Assume that Goodhealth Clinic has fixed costs of $1,000,000 and a total cost forecast of $1,500,000 at a volume of 20,000 patient visits. What is the clinic's variable cost rate? a. $25 b. $20 c. $15 d. $10 e. $ 5 Question 2 Assume that John Richards..

Health care provider and faith diversity : Does the paper provide sufficient evidence for its hypothesis or claim?

Write research paper on coca-cola marketing in china and usa : Write a research paper about Coca-Cola marketing in China and the United States.

How the poet used literary conventions and poetic devices : Include your interpretation of the poet's thoughts and feelings, along with details about how the poet used literary conventions and poetic devices such as meter.

Part of a medical experiment : In 1964, patients at a hospital in New York were injected by doctors with live cancer cells as part of a medical experiment. The patients were not told the true nature of the injections they were receiving

Evaluate the mismatch vector after this single iteration : For the system below, assume PG2=0.3, IV2I=0.95, and SD3=0.5+j0.2.Starting with Θ20=Θ30=0 and |V3|0=1.0, do one N-R iteration and find IV3I1, Θ21 and Θ31. Evaluate the mismatch vector after this single iteration

The harlem renaissance, jazz and blues music. : Does the work still resonate or have an impact on the people of our time?

What is the mediterranean diet and what foods are emphasized : What is the Mediterranean diet? What foods are emphasized? What are some differences between the Mediterranean diet and MyPlate?

Include the appropriate measures of reliability and validity : Include the appropriate measures of reliability and validity

User Account

All Pages