Otiz vs st peter case study

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics
Reference no: EM13871943

Otiz v. St. Peter's Case Study-

1) Read the case study ("Contract Violates Antitrust Laws") and answer the two discussion questions.

2) Write a paper (1,000-1,500 words) that addresses the discussion questions. Include a detailed rationale for your answers.

3) Prepare this assignment according to the APA guidelines found in the APA Style Guide, located in the Student Success Center. An abstract is not required.

4) This assignment uses a grading rubric. Instructors will be using the rubric to grade the assignment; therefore, students should review the rubric prior to beginning the assignment to become familiar with the assignment criteria and expectations for successful completion of the assignment.

Citation: Oltz v. St. Peter's Community Hosp., 19 F.3d 1312 (9th Cir. 1994)

Facts

Oltz, a nurse anesthetist, brought an antitrust action against physician anesthesiologists and St. Peter's Community Hospital after he was terminated. Oltz had a billing agreement with the hospital, which provided 84% of the surgical services in the rural community that it served. The anesthesiologists did not like competing with the nurse anesthetist's lower fees and, as a result, entered into an exclusive contract with the hospital on April 29, 1980, in order to squeeze the nurse anesthetist out of the market. This resulted in cancellation of
the nurse anesthetist's contract with the hospital.

Oltz filed a suit against the anesthesiologists and hospital for violation of the Sherman Antitrust Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1. The anesthesiologists settled for $462,500 before trial. The case against the hospital proceeded to trial. The jury found that the hospital conspired with the anesthesiologists and awarded the plaintiff $212,182 in lost income and $209,649 in future damages. The trial judge considered the damage award to be excessive and ordered a new trial. The hospital motioned the court to exclude all damages after June 26, 1982, which was the date that the hospital renegotiated its exclusive contract with the anesthesiology group. The court decided that Oltz failed to prove that the renegotiated contract also violated antitrust laws, thus ruling that Oltz was not entitled to damages after June 26, 982.

Because Oltz conceded that he could not prove damages greater than those offset by his settlement with the physicians, his claim for damages against the hospital was disposed of by summary judgment.

The judge who presided over Oltz's request for attorneys' fees restricted the amount that he could claim. Because Oltz had been denied damages from the hospital, the judge refused to award attorneys' fees or costs for work performed after the 1986 liability trial.

Issue

Was Oltz entitled to seek recovery for all damages resulting from destruction of his business after June 26, 1982?

Holding

The US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit held that Oltz was entitled to seek recovery for all damages.

Reason

Oltz introduced evidence that the initial exclusive contract violated antitrust laws and that such violation destroyed his practice. "Because the initial conspiracy destroyed his practice, Oltz is entitled to seek recovery for all damages resulting from the destruction of his business. . . . The legality of any subsequent agreements between the conspirators is irrelevant, because the April 29, 1980, contract severed the lifeline to Oltz's thriving practice. . ."

Discussion

1. What should parties to a contract be aware of when negotiating exclusive contracts?

2. What remedies are available when one party breaches a contract by refusing to perform an agreed-upon service?

Reference no: EM13871943

Questions Cloud

Difference between project-based and non-project-based tasks : difference between project-based and non-project-based tasks
Aquarium consists of thick plastic : A large aquarium of height 5.00 m is filled with fresh water to a depth of 2.00 m. One wall of the aquarium consists of thick plastic 8.00 m wide. By how much does the total force on that wall increase if the aquarium is next filled to a depth of ..
A figure skater rotates about a vertical axis : A car is stopped for a traffic signal. When the light turns green, the car accelerates, increasing its speed from zero to 4.89 m/s over a time interval of 0.522 s. What impulse and average force does a 74 kg passenger in the car experience?
Insto photo company purchased merchandise, : Insto uses the calendar year as its fiscal year and uses the perpetual inventory system.
Otiz vs st peter case study : Otiz v. St. Peter's Case Study- What should parties to a contract be aware of when negotiating exclusive contracts
Explain and detail the stages in adlerian therapy : Explain and detail the stages in Adlerian therapy.
Evaluate the financial performance of a company : Evaluate the financial performance of a company of your choosing using the knowledge and technical skills that you have gained during the course so far. Provide a theoretical explanation of any ratio analysis. No need to recalculate ratios, often ..
What was the percentage change in the real exchange rate : What was the percentage change in the real exchange rate, x0¥/SFr, during the year? What was the percentage change in the relative purchasing power of the franc?
Who is kevin matnick? : Who is Kevin Matnick?

Reviews

Write a Review

Business Law and Ethics Questions & Answers

  Measuring and comparing crime

Measuring and Comparing Crime, You have been appointed head of a United Nations agency tasked with collecting transnational crime statistics. Determine the strategy that you would utilize for collecting, compiling

  Analyze whether the suit can be brought in federal court

Analyze whether the suit can be brought in federal court and Explain the advantages and disadvantages of federal versus state court for this type of suit

  Demonstrate strong corporate ethics

lease discuss the ethical lessons that you learned in this class that will help you in the future. Research a company that demonstrates strong corporate ethics and discuss why the company is a good example of corporate ethics, leadership and applic..

  What the leader states is then passed

This is characterized by 1 leader who acts like a dictator and makes every decision. What the leader states is then passed as the directives to subordinates who will carry out these directives under very close supervision

  Historical development of policing in the united states

Write a 700- to 1,050-word paper that describes how the historical development of policing in the United States relates to the current relationship between police and different ethnic groups and social classes

  Identify the reinforcement strategies used by management

Write a 1,400- to 2,100-word paper on reinforcement strategies applied in team members' organizations. Identify the reinforcement strategies used by management to motivate employees

  Where and how to search for appropriate research materials

This portion of the Application is designed to help you discover where and how to search for appropriate research materials. Here, you are not engaging in a full review of the literature as you might do for a research paper, a KAM, or your final t..

  What information federal agencies have about grapple

Grapple Market Share Corporation would like to know what information federal agencies have about Grapple's operations, so that the firm will know what its competitors may be able to learn about it. Can Grapple require the agencies to dis­close whatev..

  Cases of richard baumhammers and timothy mcveigh

Compare and contrast the cases of Richard Baumhammers and Timothy McVeigh. Discuss how their cases exemplify the threat of domestic terrorism in the United States

  Describe the companys ethical obligation

Explain the situation of the event - Describe the company's ethical obligation in their communications to the public.

  Discuss how war is beneficial to society

Please write a research paper (4-5) pages MLA format, in which you discuss how war is beneficial to society

  An authorized program planted on a computer is known as

An authorized program planted on a computer is known as

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd