Optimistic about the health supplements market in southeast

Reference no: EM131084825

Andrew and Brandon are two ambitious young men who were optimistic about the health supplements market in Southeast Asia and so they started a trading company a few months ago, called Alternative Health Pty Ltd ("AHPL"). Both are shareholders and directors of the company - Andrew being the Managing Director and Brandon a non-executive director. There is a third shareholder, Charles, with 15% shareholding in AHPL. In order to lend credibility to AHPL, Andrew and Brandon persuaded a common friend, Dennis, who is a trained pharmacist, to be the third director of the company. Dennis agreed reluctantly on the understanding that he was just going to be a "sleeping" (i.e. passive) director.

AHPL ordered various health products from manufacturers in Australia on credit, with the view of exporting them to distributors in SE Asia. Unfortunately, soon after the first few orders were delivered to AHPL, its target markets went into economic recession and consumers' demand for non-necessity goods dipped drastically. AHPL managed to sell some stocks at discount so as to pay its suppliers. However, it had used up most of its working capital and was running low on cash flow to pay for its operating expenses.

One day, an unsolicited customer walked in to AHPL's office-cum-warehouse and identified himself as a parallel importer for SE Asia markets. He gave AHPL staff a name card that shows his office address in Sydney CBD. He wanted to buy some health supplements in bulk and carry the goods upon presentation of a cheque for $50,000. He needed toimmediately transport the goods to the airport to catch a flight later that day. If AHPL would not sell on the spot, this customer would give it a miss. Andrew happened to be in the office and he was desperate to clear the unsold stocks. He authorised the staff to release the goods before the cheque was cleared by their bank as it was already past 3 pm. Andrew assessed that this well-dressed customer, who spoke confidently,was a decent businessman. To his horror, AHPL's bank informed them the next day that the cheque was dishonoured - it being a forged document. The cost of goods lost amounted to about $30,000.

Brandon has his other own business, providing business consultancy to Chinese clients wanting to do business in Australia. Undeterred by what happened to AHPL, Brandon believed that their bad luck would be temporary. He read from articles in reputable business newsmagazines published in Hong Kong that China would soon relax the rules on importation of foreign-made health supplements. He believed this would be an opportunity to turn around AHPL's fate. Andrew was a little concerned initially, having just made a mistake, but he did not want to see the business closed down so soon. Brandon assured Andrew that a business analyst friend had also shared with him that the Chinese market would be the next growth engine of demand for health supplements. So, they procured AHPL to order larger quantities of goods from its suppliers on credit.

This turned out to be a poor business call. In the following week, the Chinese government issued a notice quashing the rumour about relaxation on import. At the same time, the Chinese newspapers published some research reports about the adverse side effects of certain health supplements. All the prospective Chinese distributors declined to place orders with AHPL. This time, AHPL defaulted on payments to its suppliers.

Charles learns about the $30,000 loss and tells Andrew he will sue Andrew for compensation. He also wants to hold Andrew and Brandon responsible for purchasing excessive stock which could not be sold, and as a result causing AHPL to become insolvent. AHPL's suppliers threaten to apply to the court to wind up AHPL and to hold all three directors personally liable for the debts owed to the suppliers.

Discuss:

(a) Whether Andrew has any liability for the $30,000 loss; (5 marks)

(b) Whether Andrew and/or Brandon has/have any liability for purchasing excessive stock and causing AHPL to become insolvent;

(d) Assuming a director probably has liability under question (a) or (b), whether Charles himself can sue that director for damages; and

(e) Whether there is ground for ASIC to step in to take action against any director. ( 2 marks)

The word limit is minimum 1,000 words and maximum 1,200 words.

Reference no: EM131084825

Questions Cloud

Determine the transfer function and difference equation : Use MATLAB to plot the magnitude and phase frequency responses.

Form of asexual reproduction in plants : What name is given to a form of asexual reproduction in plants where structures become detached from the parent plant and develop into new plants genetically identically to the parent plant.

Compute the statement of cost of goods manufactured : The following information was available for Hamilton Industries for the year 20XX: Prepare the 20XX statement of cost of goods manufactured. Prepare the 20XX income statement.

Net energy gain of the process : How many ATP molecules are produced after in aerobic respiration and what is the net energy gain of the process?

Optimistic about the health supplements market in southeast : Andrew and Brandon are two ambitious young men who were optimistic about the health supplements market in Southeast Asia and so they started a trading company a few months ago, called Alternative Health Pty Ltd ("AHPL"). Both are shareholders and ..

Respiratory chain occur : Where in the mitochondria does the process called the respiratory chain occur? Which products of the Krebs cycle are used in that final phase of aerobic respiration?

Difference between a plant cell and an animal cell : What is the main difference between a plant cell and an animal cell?

Do you have any other ideas to reinforce proper policing : Some locales are imposing or considering laws that put local police on the front lines of immigration enforcement, while others create so-called "sanctuaries," officially prohibiting their officers from investigating legal immigration status. How ..

Grow ferns for the high school graduation : A high school biology class decided to grow ferns for the high school graduation. They knew that the sporophyte stage was the "showy" stage in the life cycle. They reasoned that all they had to do was plant spores and that they would germinate to ..

User Account

All Pages