Is this a convincing proof for the existence of moral knowle

Reference no: EM133231345

Case: Moral Knowledge Renford Bambrough offers the following proof that we have moral knowledge. My proof that we have moral knowledge consists essentially in saying, "We know that this child, who is about to undergo what would otherwise be painful surgery, should be given an anaesthetic before the operation. Therefore we know at least one moral proposition to be true." I argue that no proposition that could plausibly be alleged as a reason in favour of doubting the truth of the proposition that the child should be given an anaesthetic can possibly be more certainly true than that proposition itself. If a philosopher produces an argument against my claim to know that the child should be given an anaesthetic, I can therefore be sure in advance that either at least one of the premises of his argument is false, or there is a mistake in the reasoning by which he purports to derive from his premises the conclusion that I do not know that the child should be given an anaesthetic.

Question: Is this a convincing proof for the existence of moral knowledge? Why or why not? Is it also a convincing proof for the existence of universal moral principles? Why or why not? What moral principle underlies the judgment made in this case?

Reference no: EM133231345

Questions Cloud

Bridges are practically falling down : PHIL 140 University of Saskatchewan, Improvements would create jobs for millions of workers, Our transit system is in dire need of repair

Impacts of these interventions on patient behavior : Identify security threats associated with COVID-19. What are the impacts of these interventions on patient's behavior?

Write reflection essay on disorders of trauma and stress : Write reflection essay on Disorders of Trauma and Stress. Brief discussion on the main topic --background of the disorder

Business structure is best in to enter global competition : Which form of business structure is the best in order to enter global competition?

Is this a convincing proof for the existence of moral knowle : Is this a convincing proof for the existence of moral knowledge? Why or why not? Is it also a convincing proof for the existence of universal moral principles

Difference between the kantian and the virtue contextualist : KIN 420 California State University, Explain the difference between the Kantian and the virtue contextualist oriented approach (based on phronesis) to coaching

Mostbl outrageous waste of shareholder funds : Do you think Facebooks purchase of Whatsapp for 22 billion is either: the mostbl outrageous waste of shareholder funds?

Online marketing of flemington racecourse : Describe the marketing techniques and target audience for the online marketing of Flemington Racecourse.

List the steps that occur in order when cell becomes hypoxic : What happens to the pH inside the cell during anerobic respiration? List the steps that occur in order when a cell becomes hypoxic

User Account

All Pages