Is the district attorney correct

Assignment Help Management Theories

Reference no: EM131378389

Richard Ceballos worked as a deputy district attorney for the city of Los Angeles. Ceballos wrote a memo in which he criticized the accuracy of an affidavit in a case that he had been assigned to handle. In the memo, he expressed doubt about the truthfulness of another employee in the department. Ceballos also testified in court about his doubts in relation to the affidavit.

Afterward, Ceballos was victimized by reassignments, transfers, and the loss of a promotion. He argued that the actions of his superiors violated his right to speak freely about this problem in his department. The district attorney's office argued that a public employee's right to free speech could be limited by a state agency when that speech was made in the exercise of his or her official duties. Ceballos argued that his free speech rights, as guaranteed by the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, trumped any state action.

The district attorney argued that the power to control the right of free speech in relation to public employees had devolved to the states. Is the district attorney correct? Explain.

Garcetti, et al. v. Ceballos, 126 S. Ct. 1951 (U.S. Supreme Court).

Reference no: EM131378389

Questions Cloud

What sources might court consider when interpreting statute : This case clearly involves a difference of opinion on the interpretation of a statute. What sources might the court consider when interpreting the statute in question?

Diversity and inclusion and gender : Analyze the significance of three (3) key aspects of the relationship between diversity and business profitability. Support your rationale with two (2) examples of said relationship.

How do you feel your typology fit into your strategic plan= : You will be exploring your Meyers-Briggs Typology and determining your ethics approach associated with it. How do you feel your typology will fit into your personal strategic plan that you completed over the last two units.

Find the maximum stress at the shaft fillet : Find the maximum stress at the shaft fillet. The critical shaft fillet is 70 mm from B.

Is the district attorney correct : The district attorney argued that the power to control the right of free speech in relation to public employees had devolved to the states. Is the district attorney correct? Explain.

What classification approach is currently used in the dsm : Personality disorders are chronic and persistent behavioral and emotional disturbances that are often difficult to treat. Some professionals have argued that these disorders are not mental disorders at all, but personality styles-that these indivi..

Is the plaintiff correct : Therefore, the plaintiff concluded, Congress did not intend to preempt state tort law in this case either. Is the plaintiff correct? Explain.

Create a plan to keep the given customers business : You are informed that you can no longer provide these "special" discounts to this customer. Create a plan to keep this customer's business.

Should statute be upheld or overturned given these arguments : Therefore, the attorney general concluded, the health care law is unconstitutional. Should the statute be upheld or overturned given these arguments? Explain.

User Account

All Pages