Is opinion protected by the first amendment

Reference no: EM13251640

Two disc jockeys at WPYX-FM radio in Albany, New York, were sued for intentional infliction of emotional distress by Annette Esposito-Hilder, who was identified on the air by the two disc jockeys as the "winner" of the "ugliest bride" contest. The two disc jockeys had sponsered an ugliest bride contest based on wedding pictures in the daily newspaper . Viewers were invited to call in with their guesses as to which bride had been chosen. Generally, the disc jockeys did not reveal last names of the brides. However, in Ms. Esposito-Hilder's case, they broke with past practice and revealed her name. When a suit resulted, the cort held that no defamation was involved in their statement because they were "pure, subjective opinion: The court did hold, however that a suit for intentional infliction of emotional distress could go forward. The court held, "Comedic expression does not receive absolute First Amendment protection"

Question

Is opinion protected by the First Amendment? Does it make any difference that Ms. Esposito-Hidler was employed by a competing radio station in the area at the time she "won" the contest? [Esposito-Hilder v SFX Broadcasting, Inc., 665 N>Y>S 2d 697 (1997).]

Reference no: EM13251640

Questions Cloud

Growing diversit of the healthcre workforce affects : Identify three ways the growing diversit of the healthcre workforce affects the management ofa healthare organization today.

Consider a copper-nickel solid solution containing : Consider a copper-nickel solid solution containing (4.00x10^1) at% copper. How many atoms per cubic centimeter (atoms/cm^3) of copper are there in this solution?

Is the Sarbanes-Oxley Act too restrictive : Is the Sarbanes-Oxley Act too restrictive? Is it too burdensome on mid-sized companies? Explain your answer.

Summarize two of the four federal antitrust statutes : Summarize two of the four Federal Antitrust Statutes (Sherman Act, Clayton Act, FTC Act or Robinson-Patman Act). How do they affect today's business?

Is opinion protected by the first amendment : Two disc jockeys at WPYX-FM radio in Albany, New York, were sued for intentional infliction of emotional distress by Annette Esposito-Hilder, who was identified on the air by the two disc jockeys as the "winner" of the "ugliest bride" contest. The t..

Consider a copper-nickel solid solution : Consider a copper-nickel solid solution containing (4.00x10^1) at% copper. How many atoms per cubic centimeter (atoms/cm^3) of copper are there in this solution?

What is the best annotated bibliography : What is the best Annotated Bibliography for the narrative writing "If I Could Only See One Color"? (history, facts/figures, compelling quotations)

Annual family dental expenses for the families : Annual family dental expenses for the families of a random sample of ten employees of a company are given below. You can assume the family dental expenses for the employees of the company are normally distributed.

Explain how the owners and sponsors of commercial sports : Explain how the owners and sponsors of commercial sports have benefited from their ability to establish cartels, monopolies, and monopsonies within the business of sports.

User Account

All Pages