Is it immoral for the parents to withhold surgery

Reference no: EM133476629

Assignment:

Prompt

About one baby out of every 600 born in the U.S. has Down's syndrome. Many of these children are born with fatal physical conditions that can cause quite a bit of pain and suffering. For instance, a baby with Down's syndrome could be born with part of their vital organs missing, intestines might be blocked, and their heart might not pump properly. Surgery is often required for these infants to survive beyond the first few days of life.

Parents must decide whether to allow surgery to save the child, who may end up requiring costly long-term care and services for life or withholding permission thus causing the child to die.

Is it immoral for the parents to withhold surgery? Likewise, is it immoral for the parents to allow the surgery?
Is the assumption that parents will act in the best interest of their child justified?
Morally speaking, would the physician deciding not to operate be tantamount to murder?
Ethicist James Rachels (1975) uses the Baby Does case to illustrate how passive euthanasia can sometimes cause more suffering than active euthanasia. If it is morally permissible for parents to allow their infants to die, should active euthanasia be used instead?
Considering the moral issues related to quality and sanctity of life, the principle of do no harm, and palliative care, are there ever any cases when euthanasia of an infant is morally justified?

Reference

Rachels, J. (1975). Active and passive euthanasia. New England Journal of Medicine, 292(2), 78-81.

Reference no: EM133476629

Questions Cloud

What is referred to as a food desert : As a result, what does this do to the health and well-being of the thousands of people living in that community?

How can human services providers promote cultural competence : How can human services providers promote cultural competence and inclusivity within their organizations to better serve diverse populations.

What role does the type of economic system play on education : What role does the type of economic system play on education and students' experience? Do free education impact students' experience, pass rates.

Explain two sociological theory : Explain which one or two sociological theory(ies) (functionalism, conflict theory, and symbolic interactionism) best describes view of education?

Is it immoral for the parents to withhold surgery : Is it immoral for the parents to withhold surgery? Likewise, is it immoral for the parents to allow the surgery?

Should health care in us be treated as a human rights : Should health care in the United States be treated as a human right? Why or why not?

What does the pro-choice movement represent : What does the pro-choice movement represent? How has it been used to spread awareness and/or promote a social movement?

What ethical issues and ethical reasoning are argued : What ethical issues and ethical reasoning are argued? Do you think that the issues discussed have moral and ethical implications? Why or why not?

Do you think that article 42 would end the boarder crisis : Do you think that article 42 would end the boarder crisis?

User Account

All Pages