Is human life additive

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM13943897

1. You are the engineer of a trolley.

2. The trolley has gotten almost out of control.

3. Your only choice left is to switch at Lincoln Junction between A-track and B-track.

4. You are approaching Lincoln Junction and on the RIGHT track is a school bus filled with 50 innocent young children whose bus got caught in the trolley tracks.

5. The LEFT track is occupied by a homeless person whose poor-fitting shoe has caught in the trolley tracks.

6. As the engineer, you have the choice of moving your lethal train to the right or left. This is your only choice.

Does one have any moral justification for going to the right or to the left? Clearly, most of us would kill one rather than 50. But do we have the moral justification for doing so? Is human life additive? How can we assess such examples? Is it the case that there are no moral reasons for choosing one track over another (as a deontologist might argue), and that if one chooses to save the school bus, you do so for other nonmoral reasons?

Reference no: EM13943897

Questions Cloud

Trait theory of leadership : How many of you ascribe to the trait theory of leadership which implies that leaders are born--not made or shaped by mentors or by being a follower first
Difference in the mean selling price of homes : Refer to the real estate data in Blackboard. Determine whether there is a difference in the mean selling price of homes with an attached garage and homes without an attached garage.
Range of output theoretically possible : An assembly line with 17 tasks is to be balanced. The longest task is 2.3 minutes, and the total time for all tasks is 18 minutes. The line will operate for 460 minutes per day.
Total bond interest expense : the amount of the premium on these bonds at issuance total bond interest expense will be recognized over the life of these bonds
Is human life additive : Does one have any moral justification for going to the right or to the left? Clearly, most of us would kill one rather than 50. But do we have the moral justification for doing so? Is human life additive?
Describe the worst case scenario for quick sort algorithm. : Any ideas to improve the worst case? Comment on the improvement in running time vs. increase in code complexity.
Both substantive and form aspects : Expect your answers to be no more than one page per question.  You are encouraged to utilize as muchof the material from the first three chapters of the text as possible, and the best answers will recognizeand refute counterarguments.  Your grade wil..
Which federal law has the physician violated : A civil lawsuit may arise if a physician shares a patient's medical information without the patient's consent. If this occurs, which federal law has the physician violated
The largest corporation in the world : Wal-Mart is the largest corporation in the world, and it has obviously enjoyed tremendous success. But while many welcome its location in their communities, others do not. Some complain that its presence has too many negative effects on a communit..

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Discuss the budgetary and managerial impact

Write a paper, not to exceed 1,200 words, in which you evaluate the use od body worn cameras on police officers. Discuss the budgetary and managerial impact of the present trend or the future trend.

  Find the mean-median-mode-variance-standard deviation

Find the mean, median, mode, variance, standard deviation, and range for the following sample of quiz scores: 2, 3, 4, 4, 5, 5, 6, 6, 7, 7, 7, 8, 8, 9, 9

  Inter-nationalist and transformationalist theories

Using the three positions on change, the globalization, inter-nationalist and transformationalist theories. Drawing on evidence from culture or economics or politics and ideas about winners and losers

  Explain the role ethics play in experimentation write some

compare and contrast watsons classical conditioning model of behavior and skinners operant conditioning model. give

  Mobility of people between countries

Globalization has caused extensive shifts in the mobility of people between countries. Economics, political shifts, and increased opportunities for travel have made migration and immigration pervasive.

  Demographic transition model issues

what factors lead to a decline of the CDR in phase two and the CBR in phase three of the demographic transition?

  Global monoculture be good thing or bad thing

Why do critics of globalization say that it is causing a loss of distinct, local cultures in many countries around the world? In what ways might a global “monoculture” be a good thing or a bad thing? Remember to keep your work focused on what you are..

  Describe the changes in predominant health problems

Your lectures in the first half of our course discuss major events in U.S. healthcare history and key changes over time. Briefly describe the changes in predominant health problems among Americans since good record keeping began in the 1800s.

  Routine low anterior resection

A 52 year-old woman undergoes a routine low anterior resection for colon cancer and has a temperature of 104° six hours post-op. You look at her wound and it looks purple around the edges and there seems to be some gray drainage.

  Are there gender differences in the sex drives

Are there gender differences in the sex drives? If yes what account for theses differences.

  The network diagram is the besttool for demonstrating

A critical resource usedin project management that can neither be inventoried nor renewedis: The network diagram is the besttool for demonstrating:

  Distinctive physiological pattern

Women are expected to be kind and attentive to other people's feelings. In North America, when a woman in the workplace doesn't smile when others expect her to, she is likely to:

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd