If you were a member of the jury, what would you do

Assignment Help Financial Accounting

Reference no: EM133433552

Expected Values of Questionable Decisions

The members of the jury had to make a decision in a lawsuit brought by the State of Alabama against Exxon Mobil. The suit revolved around natural-gas wells that Exxon drilled in state-owned waters. After signing several leases obligating Exxon to share revenues with Alabama, company officials started questioning the terms of the agreement that prohibited deducting several types of processing costs before paying the state royalties.

During the course of the trial, a memo by an in-house attorney of Exxon Mobil came to light. The memo noted that Royal Dutch Shell, which had signed a similar lease, interpreted it "in the same manner as the state." The memo then presented arguments the company might use to claim the deduction, estimated the probability of the arguments being successful (less than 50%), and proceeded to consider whether Exxon should obey the law using a cost-benefit analysis. According to the memo, "If we adopt anything beyond a "safe" approach, we should anticipate a quick audit and subsequent litigation." The memo also observed that "our exposure is 12 percent interest on underpayments calculated from the due date, and the cost of litigation." Deducting the questionable costs did, indeed, result in an audit and a lawsuit.

Required

If you were a member of the jury, what would you do? Why?

Reference no: EM133433552

Questions Cloud

Will the public policy exception to the employment-at-will : Who are individuals in the workforce who are currently unprotected by civil rights laws. Will the public policy exception to the employment-at-will doctrine

Analyze the sources of the conflict : Identify an intergroup (team) conflict that you have experienced in the workplace, school, or home Explain the intergroup (team) conflict you have experienced

Calculate the nav of the fund : Will the NAV increase or decrease and Calculated your return on your investment given the change in NAV

Define the differences between a multinational and global : Should the company set a world-wide policy regarding employment discrimination based on sexual orientation? (this is your recommendation - yes or no)

If you were a member of the jury, what would you do : Deducting the questionable costs did, indeed, result in an audit and a lawsuit. Required If you were a member of the jury, what would you do? Why

What ideas might juanita have on how bill can improve : What ideas might Juanita have on how Bill can improve his monthly budget so he can start to pay off his debts? Based on Juanita's recommendations in #2

What is the price of the stock : The required rate of return by the investors is 10.0%. The investors also expect 3.0% growth. Based on the common stock (growth) model, what is the price

What are the costs and benefits for management of allowing : What are the costs and benefits for management of allowing the union to decide how the economic package should be divided? What demands would most likely be

Discuss the debt initial public offering : Describe how you approached these calculations. Also discuss the tax shield advantage that debt capital provides, and briefly explain the cost of capital

User Account

All Pages