Reference no: EM133485451

Question 1: Examine the situation and describe the ethical and/or moral question,

Question 2: Describe what you believe to be the motivation of the actor and the potential consequences of BOTH/EACH options,

Question 3: Identify the decision you believe the actor SHOULD make, and

Provide the ethical basis for your decision.

Question 4:  Connect the ethical basis for your decision to ethical theories introduced at the beginning of the course and explain the rationale for this connection.

Each decision must be considered separately and not be influenced by earlier decisions and actions.

The judge

Judge Jeffery Owens is very troubled by the felony case before him. The defendant, Woodrow Wilson, had been found guilty of armed robbery of a liquor store. The case alleged that Wilson had a handgun in plain sight when he entered the Sin-Yon liquor store, that he hit the owner in the head with the weapon and forced him to open the cash drawer. Fleeing the scene on foot, Woodrow only got a few blocks before responding police officers spotted him and made the arrest. The prosecutor, armed with the recovered cash, video surveillance and an eyewitness as evidence had an easy case. Now it is time for sentencing.

Jeffery saw the demonstration of business owners in the hallway when he entered the courthouse that morning. They were chanting "Justice for our victims" and were demanding a lengthy prison sentence. The Pre-Sentence Investigation report said Wilson was suffering from acute addiction and associated mental problems that had caused these past violent (but not criminal) outbreaks. There is no information in the file that Wilson has ever received treatment for his disorders. Jeffery knows that, due to budget cuts, the state prison system has very little in the way of addictive or behavioral disorder treatment programs. The prisons had reverted to merely warehousing inmates. However, he had read that the county jail had received a federal grant to establish precisely the services it appeared Wilson needed. Obviously, he did not know if this or any treatment would be successful for Wilson.

Sentencing guidelines were established to ensure defendants convicted of similar offenses received similar punishments. According to the sentencing guidelines, Wilson should be sentenced to 5-7 years in the state correctional prison system. Jeffery knows that the business community was calling for the maximum sentence. The county jail only took inmates sentenced to eighteen months or less. What sentence should Judge Owens impose on Mr. Wilson?