Hume view of soul

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM1386358

Two people are debating on weather souls exist or not one person says they do and the other says they dont. Someone walks up who holds a Humean view and reads the last sentence of Hume's Inquiry:

"When we run over libraries, persuaded of these principles, what havoc must we make? If we take in our hand any volume; of divinity or school metaphysics, for instance; let us ask, Does it contain any abstract reasoning concerning quantity or number? No. Does it contain any experimental reasoning concerning matter of fact and existence? No. Commit it then to the flames: for it can contain nothing but sophistry and illusion."

That person then says that this means one of them is right and one of them is wrong.

What does this person mean, which person is wrong? And what are they wrong about? How can this person justify telling one them they are wrong? What might they other person say to defend their view?

I am not asking for very long answers I've read Inquiry over and over but I can not grasp where Hume stands on souls and how using that view you can tell someone they are wrong or not on their view.

Reference no: EM1386358

Questions Cloud

Communication style in making a report : In regards to the statistics paper you helped me with. Can you do a conclusion of the findings. I can edit it to my communication style, but I do need to do the following:
Challenging soft deductions : For each of the following arguments, try to think of some critical information that could weaken or discount conclusion. How could the argument be expressed to eliminate the weakness?
Create logic for application which reads in name of item : Products shown in accompanying table. Create the logic for application which reads in name of the item ordered by the customer and outputs either?
Hemoglobin values : Hematocrit values may be estimated from hemoglobin values by multiplying the hemoglobin value by three. Discuss how do the actual hematocrit values of your sample compare with the computed value obtained from the hemoglobin concentration?
Hume view of soul : Two people are debating on weather souls exist or not one person says they do and the other says they dont. Someone walks up who holds a Humean view and reads the last sentence of Hume's Inquiry:
Does not require any additional oil between filter changes : does not require any additional oil between filter changes. If the oil costs $1.08 per quarts, what is the maximum acceptable price for the Type Y filter?
Example of conditioanl : Provide example of conditioanl where, the antecedent is false and the consequent is true, and conditional is true. Also where the conditional is false.
The foreman states that he spends twice : The foreman states that he spends twice as much time supervising A and half as much time supervising B,compared with the average time spent supervising his other subordinates.
Open-addressing hashing method using quadratic probing : Write down the next four (4) locations we will attempt (suppose they also have collisions) if we are using Quadratic Probing?

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  What is an anthropometric variable

What is an anthropometric variable? In what ways can anthropometric data be used at the workplace for the design of a manhole to be provided in a confined space for maintenance purposes? How would you identify ergonomic problems in a construct..

  Adolescents to the young adult stages

This aligns with the process of development in which maturity occurs from adolescents to the young adult stages. I am interested to hear your take on this?

  Determining moral responsibility

Under what situation can human beings be held morally responsible for what they do? If our actions are determined by other influences, does that get us off the hook, or should we accept responsibility even in cases where we could not have done oth..

  Changing patterns of social mobility in us

Suppose you've the opportunity to do research on changing patterns of social mobility in the U.S. What specific question would you want to investigate, and how would you go about it?

  What is difference between internal also external validity

Involves degree to which individuals feels secure or insecure in relying on ors, opening up to them also being intimate with them what are types of love also how do they differ.

  Difference between position and prestige

Max Weber's classic work on social class distinguishes between position and prestige. Critically discuss  the difference?

  Define international and transnational crime

Define international and transnational crime and describe how they differ in nature?

  Explaining the bilateral valid contract-legal consideration

If on December 10th, the Centennial Hall burned to the ground through no fault of Business Bldg., would Quality be able to sue Business Bldg.

  Conditioned versus unconditioned responses

It gives a description of unconditioned responses and stimuli as well.

  Dilution factor for conducting a bod5 test

In order for BOD results to be valid, it is desirable to maintain a minimum dissolved oxygen concentration at the end of the incubation period of at least 1.0 mg/L. If an industrial wastewater is known to have a COD of 1000 mg/L, recommend a dilut..

  Validity and data-method types in research

Define and explain the kinds of reliability. Provide examples of these types of reliability as they apply to human services research or to human services management research.

  Specific instructions for baking a german chocolate cake

Although she had not received any specific instructions for baking a German chocolate cake, Jamie had watched her mother do so many times.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd