Reference no: EM133607816

Question: Discuss with another student or person how your personal idea or event compares and contrasts with one of Brandenburg's ideas in Imported Americans. Write two conclusions from this discussion.

Essay- The excerpts from Brandenburg's book provide insights into the lives of Italian immigrants in America, particularly those from the better social classes. These immigrants, like Chevalier Tonella and his wife, represent a unique group that had a significant impact on the Italian community in the United States. As I reflect on these passages, I can draw connections to my personal experiences, particularly in understanding the dynamics of immigrant communities and the persistence of social hierarchies among them.

In my personal experience, I have observed how immigrant communities often maintain certain social distinctions and hierarchies even after settling in a new country. Brandenburg's description of Chevalier Tonella and his wife, who were once part of the European aristocracy but are now running businesses in America, resonates with my encounters with immigrants who carry their social backgrounds with them.

I have encountered individuals in immigrant communities who, despite adapting to their new surroundings and embracing American citizenship, continue to hold on to their social status from their home country. They may maintain certain customs, traditions, and preferences for imported goods, much like the Italians described in the text. For example, some immigrants may insist on wearing clothes of their native country's style or send their children to private schools where their language and culture are preserved. This phenomenon reflects a desire to preserve their heritage and maintain a sense of identity within a foreign land.

Furthermore, Brandenburg's observation that Italians of humble birth in America may show deference to those who are well-born resonates with my experiences within immigrant communities. I have witnessed instances where individuals who have achieved success in the host country may still show respect to those from higher social strata, even if such distinctions may have faded in the broader American society. This phenomenon highlights the persistence of social hierarchies within immigrant communities, where respect for traditional norms and values can often take precedence over assimilation into the broader culture.

In conclusion, the excerpts from Brandenburg's book shed light on the complex dynamics of immigrant communities, particularly those from better social classes who have emigrated to the United States. My personal experiences have confirmed that even in the process of assimilation and adaptation to a new culture, individuals from such backgrounds may continue to uphold their social status and traditions from their home country. This phenomenon underscores the importance of understanding the multifaceted nature of immigrant communities and the lasting impact of social hierarchies within them.