How would utilitarian ethics respond, and why

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM133548721

Case Study: Imagine you work in a hospital. You discover that a doctor is about to make an important decision. "Dr. X" is doing research that might help save many hundreds of thousands, or even millions, of lives. But to complete that research, she needs to actively kill a perfectly healthy person to study how a recently-dead, healthy heart works. There are no volunteers, and there is no time to wait for a volunteer.

"Dr. X" has decided to use a much older, homeless person with no friends or family. No one but you and the doctor know this is about to happen. The homeless person will not experience any pain as a result of the experiment. Let's also say, for the purpose of this scenario, that "Dr. X" won't get "caught" unless you say something to the authorities. You're wondering whether or not you should try to stop Dr. X, perhaps by publicizing what she's going to do and getting the authorities involved.

Questions: Answer these questions:

(a) How would utilitarian ethics respond, and why?

(b) How would Kantian ethics respond, and why?

(c) And which side, if either, has the most rational and well-argued position--and why?

 

Reference no: EM133548721

Questions Cloud

How does the chief maintain the progress the department has : how does the chief deal with tensions felt in the law enforcement community since Ferguson, Baltimore, Dallas, and the rise of shootings against the police?
Explain the controversy of establishing a court system : Explain the controversy of establishing a court system at the creation of the U.S. Constitution. Your responses must include the major elements
How would you include on the erd the need to represent : How would you include on the ERD the need to represent the date on which a patient is admitted for each time he or she is admitted
How would you as the leader ensure that all cultures : Are leadership visions for organizations inadequate if not shared with constituents? What are the implications associated with sharing, or not sharing
How would utilitarian ethics respond, and why : How would utilitarian ethics respond, and why? How would Kantian ethics respond, and why? which side, if either, has the most rational and well-argued position
What is your opinion on the relative clarity : What is your opinion on the relative clarity, elegance, and efficiency of the two algorithms (using the definition and using the formula) to compute F(20)
Discuss the parts of the social ecology theory : Discuss the parts of the Social Ecology Theory and its relationship with the Broken Windows what it means for improving a neighborhood
Design the fsm as a moore fsm : Design the FSM as a Moore FSM. Use one-hot encoding and a minimum number of states. Show all of your work, including your final schematic
What were some of the presumptions in the educational system : what were some of the presumptions in the educational system that the authors referenced, and how might these sorts of presumptions relate

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Occupational therapy issues

Which trend is reflected in the centennial vision for occupational therapy?

  Identify specific skills and action would employ as advocate

Identify specific skills and actions you would employ as an advocate. For skills, please refrain from the previously used communication

  Perfectly normalized databases and denormalized databases

What are the key issues in deciding between using perfectly normalized databases and denormalized databases?

  Write on the topic - Toyota Tackles Climate Change

Write on the given Topic - Toyota Tackles Climate Change. Keep it crisp and directly related to the topic, no need for sources/references

  Emergent theories in the field of human development

What is your general view of human nature (i.e., trustworthy, good, evil, deceitful, etc.)? Do you think that it is important to talk about different stages of development or do you think that we are essentially a "bigger" version of our younger self..

  Write about an organization developing a web site

For instance, you might write about an organization developing a Web site similar to the one you are developing. In your scenario, focus on one or two problems.

  What are services that form part of a work-based network

What are services that form part of a work-based network for Aboriginal and or Torres Strait Islander people and what are their networking contact details

  Identify any presenting issues or patterns of behavior

Identify any presenting issues or patterns of behavior that brought the client into the wellness center. Describe what you observed during your initial visit

  What was the crime defendant was alleged to have committed

What was the crime the defendant was alleged to have committed? What are the elements of that crime? Is there sufficient evidence to believe the defendant guilty of this crime beyond a reasonable doubt? Explain.

  Personal and professional lives

When setting a Mission Statement and defining success for both personal and professional lives, "My/The definition of success is". Pls answer in 120 words or less and cite url or references if used.

  What symptoms is ed experiencing

Question 1: What symptoms is Ed experiencing that suggest there might be a problem?

  What challenges might an emergency manager face

You are the emergency manager in a city with a population of 250,000 in the Midwestern United States, and you have been asked to write a research paper for the National Emergency Management Association that clearly explains the risk management fra..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd