How would the legal dilemma posed in this scenario

Assignment Help Other Subject

Reference no: EM133480839

Case Study: Sam owns a resort that has over 100 employees. He hired Sandra, a Christian to serve as a housekeeper. Sandra informed him during the interview process that per her faith, she would need to have every Sunday off on the schedule as she goes to church on Sunday and believes that Sunday is the Sabbath and that she must keep it holy by not working and taking a rest. Sam, who espoused a policy of diversity, told her it wouldn't be an issue.

After the U.S. Supreme Court decision in Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores, 573 U.S. 682 (2014), Sam decided to stop paying for any kind of birth control through the health insurance that he offered his employees due to financial loss associated with the COVID-19 crisis; the business went under and numerous employees left for higher paying jobs or left out of fear of catching the virus. While the resort offered free COVID-19 vaccinations, many stated that it was against their religion to take the vaccine and opted to look for other employment.

Sam then started thinking about other ways in which religion impacted his business. After talking with his wife, he decided to tell Sandra that she could no longer be off every Sunday, as it probably was disruptive to business and bothered the other employees (as they said they were Christians too, but still had to work on Sunday and even took the vaccine to maintain their job during the economic uncertainty). He issued Sandra a letter informing her that, under her religious freedom rights as a business owner, he would no longer allow her to be off every Sunday. The next day, he got a certified letter from Sandra's lawyer telling him that he was violating her rights and unless he allowed her to continue to continue to be off every Sunday, he would be subject to a lawsuit.

Question 1

How would the legal dilemma(s) posed in this scenario likely be resolved if no Constitution existed? Does what you imagine seem impartial and/or fair to all parties?

Question 2

Using the federal Constitution "as is", assume that:

- if your last name starts with A-M, you are a paralegal assigned to assisting Sandra's lawyer.

- if your last name starts with N-Z, you are a paralegal assigned to assisting Sam's lawyer.

Reference no: EM133480839

Questions Cloud

Examine the situation at dr. patel dental practice using : Examine the situation at Dr. Patel's dental practice using the problem-solving approach, Root Cause Analysis. Develop a comprehensive paragraph detailing

Identify and list two companies for each type of e-commerce : Identify and list two companies for each type of e-commerce. Describe each company (take a screenshot of each) and explain why it fits into the category

Identify and explain the steps in the process : Identify and explain the steps in the process for effective delegation per Figure 7.5 of the course textbook.The six steps in effective delegation

Identify a patient care issue : Identify a patient care issue that provides an opportunity for a quality improvement initiative.

How would the legal dilemma posed in this scenario : How would the legal dilemma(s) posed in this scenario likely be resolved if no Constitution existed? Does what you imagine seem impartial and/or fair to all

What mistakes were made during implementation of sfa system : What mistakes were made during the implementation of the SFA system? What would you have done differently to avoid those mistakes?

What feelings or thoughts come over you as you listen : What feelings/thoughts come over you as you listen? - What does this tell you about what people thought about the power of media at the time?

How incorporating or not incorporating patient preferences : Explain how incorporating or not incorporating patient preferences, social determinants of health and values impacted the outcome of their treatment plan.

Explain when sound is not a good idea in an interface : Give reasons why and when/where audio can be useful, and give examples. Explain when sound is not a good idea in an interface, and give examples.

User Account

All Pages