How would a defender of utilitarianism or consequentialism

Assignment Help Other Subject

Reference no: EM133494060

Case Study: In Just Mercy, Bryan Stevenson, a recent Harvard Law School graduate undertakes to represent individuals on death row in Alabama. After investigating the circumstances surrounding his client Walter McMillan, known as Johnny D, he comes to believe that Johnny D was wrongfully convicted of murdering an young woman and was sentenced to death. After a great deal of work, Stevenson succeeds in getting Johnny D's conviction overturned and wins his freedom. As a first set, he decides to set up a meeting to discuss reopening the case with the new prosecutor.

Question: Write an essay in which you answer the following questions about the dilemma facing the prosecutor:

1. What make an action right according to the version of moral objectivism known as Utilitarianism/Consequentialism?

2. What make an action right according to the version of moral objectivism that is Kant's Deontology (Duty/Rule Based Moral Theory)?

3. What alternatives did Stevenson have in seeking to reopenthe case, what did he choose to do, and was it the right thing to do?

a. How would a defender of Utilitarianism/Consequentialism answer this question?

b. How would a defender of Kant's Deontology (Duty/Rule based Moral Theory) answer this question?

c. What do you think the right answer was in this case and why?

4. What alternatives did the new prosecutor have with respect to granting Stevenson's request, which alternative did he choose and was it the right thing to do?

a. How would a defender of Utilitarian/Consequentialist answer this question?

b. How would a defender of Kant's Deontology (Duty/Rule Based moral theory) answer this question?

c. What do you think is the right answer and why?

5. What were the good and bad consequences that could have followed from Stevenson's actions and why should these or should these not have determined how Stevenson approach?

Reference no: EM133494060

Questions Cloud

Which of the three most common operating systems : Which of the three most common operating systems (Linux, MacOS, and Windows} do you use most often, and what features of the 05 do you find most useful?

What gregory i believed were forms of human effort mediating : Which of the following best represents what Gregory I believed "were forms of human effort mediating with the divine"?

Examine a case of an e-commerce site : Organizations must manage and administer an e-commerce site with attention to vulnerabilities to both organizational assets and client data.

What are the materials needed to produce type of grocery bag : What are the materials needed to produce the type of grocery bag you have chosen? How are those materials extracted from the earth?

How would a defender of utilitarianism or consequentialism : What make an action right according to the version of moral objectivism known as Utilitarianism/Consequentialism? What make an action right according

How might nonstate groups like businesses, terrorists : Why study nonstate actors as a field of international politics? Will this persist in the future or do you see a swing back to sovereignty as the key organizing

Explain the current issues that the quantum leap marketing : discuss which theories help explain the current issues that the Quantum Leap Marketing Partners organization is facing, and which theories could be used to help

Provide an overview of the work you have analyzed : Provide an overview of the work you have analyzed, briefly describing the main points and your reaction to the author's claim.

How important is biological diversity for human health : How important is biological diversity for human health? What effects does the use of pesticides have on the environment and biodiversity?

User Account

All Pages