How did rousseau view man in a state of nature

Reference no: EM133321227

Case Study: Rousseau: The Extreme Democrat

Jean-Jacques Rousseau (1712-1778) was born in Geneva, Switzerland, where all adult male citizens could vote for a representative government. Rousseau traveled in France and Italy, educating himself.

In 1751, he won an essay contest. His fresh view that man was naturally good and was corrupted by society made him a celebrity in the French salons where artists, scientists, and writers gathered to discuss the latest ideas.

A few years later he published another essay in which he described savages in a state of nature as free, equal, peaceful, and happy. When people began to claim ownership of property, Rousseau argued, inequality, murder, and war resulted.

According to Rousseau, the powerful rich stole the land belonging to everyone and fooled the common people into accepting them as rulers. Rousseau concluded that the social contract was not a willing agreement, as Hobbes, Locke, and Montesquieu had believed, but a fraud against the people committed by the rich.

In 1762, Rousseau published his most important work on political theory, The Social Contract. His opening line is still striking today: "Man is born free, and everywhere he is in chains". Rousseau agreed with Locke that the individual should never be forced to give up his or her natural rights to a king.

The problem in the state of nature, Rousseau said, was to find a way to protect everyone's life, liberty, and property while each person remained free. Rousseau's solution was for people to enter a social contract. They would give up all their rights, not to a king, but to "the whole community", all the people. He called all the people the "sovereign," a term used by Hobbes to mainly refer to a king. The people then exercised their "general will" to make laws for the "public good".

Rousseau argued that the general will of the people could not be decided by elected representatives. He believed in a direct democracy in which everyone voted to express the general will and to make the laws of the land. Rousseau had in mind a democracy on a small scale, a city-state like his native Geneva.

In Rousseau's democracy, anyone who disobeyed the general will of the people "will be forced to be free". He believed that citizens must obey the laws or be forced to do so as long as they remained a resident of the state. This is a "civil state", Rousseau says, where security, justice, liberty, and property are protected and enjoyed by all.

All political power, according to Rousseau, must reside with the people, exercising their general will. There can be no separation of powers, as Montesquieu proposed. The people, meeting together, will deliberate individually on laws and then by majority vote find the general will. Rousseau's "general will" was later embodied in the words, "We the people..." at the beginning of the U.S. Constitution.

Rousseau was rather vague on the mechanics of how his democracy would work. There would be a government of sorts, entrusted with administering the general will. But it would be composed of "mere officials" who got their orders from the people.

Rousseau believed that religion divided and weakened the state. "It is impossible to live in peace with people who think you are damned," he said. He favored a "civil religion" that accepted God but concentrated on the sacredness of the social contract.

Rousseau realized that democracy as he envisioned it would be hard to maintain. He warned, "As soon as any man says of the affairs of the State, 'What does it matter to me?' the State may be given up for lost.

Question 1: Explain Rousseau's early life, education, and first successful writing experience?

Question 2: How did Rousseau view man in a state of nature?

Question 3: What, according to Rousseau, was the influence of society on man? (Particularly the ownership of property)

Question 4: How did Rousseau disagree with Hobbes, Locke, and Montesquieu regarding the idea of the social contract?

Question 5: What was the relationship between the social contract and the sovereign as stated in Rousseau's work The Social Contract?

Question 6: Explain Rousseau's ideas about direct democracy and political power. How did he view religion's relationship to the state?

Reference no: EM133321227

Questions Cloud

How do you think a character like callaghan would fare : what do you think this means? Why did people in the 1970s stop believing in traditional authority like government, the military and the police

What was the origin point of the black death : What was the origin point of the Black Death? How far did it travel? Which trade routes did the Black Death follow? Which trade routes did the Black Death

What are french politicians views towards muslims africans : What are French politicians views towards Muslims/ Africans Think about the riots described- how might they be interpreted

Why should u.s. prevent the achievement of a nuclear threat : Should the U.S. prevent the achievement of a nuclear threat by North Korea and Iran "by any means necessary"? Should we treat the two nations differently?

How did rousseau view man in a state of nature : Explain Rousseau's early life, education, and first successful writing experience? How did Rousseau view man in a state of nature?

What possible problems would asymmetric conflict create : What possible problems would asymmetric conflict create? Try to be as specific as possible and use examples if you can. What different training do you think

Discuss area impacted and reason for the third party entry : discuss the area impacted and reason for the third party entry (it will be to do with the Cold War). What was the outcome of the involvement?

What do hitler and mussolini have in common : During their early careers, before the start of World War II, what do Hitler and Mussolini have in common and how do their careers and their rise to power

How did exchange of peoples plants lead to environment : How did the exchange of peoples, plants, animals, and diseases lead to environmental changes in the Old World? Be specific and use examples.

User Account

All Pages