Highlight films was protected by the fair use doctrine

Assignment Help Business Management

Reference no: EM133097556

Jim Clark, an artist in Birmingham, submitted his logo design for the Birmingham Cougars football team, and the Cougars used a logo design that was very similar to Clark's design for their team logo during the 1996-1998 seasons. Clark sued the Cougars for copyright infringement for using his design as their logo without his permission, and the court ruled that the Cougars had improperly used Clark's design for their logo and had infringed on his copyright of that design. The Cougars changed their logo for the 1999 season, but they started showing highlight films from their 1996-1998 seasons in their stadium, on their website, and on their television channel, and the logo that Clark had designed and that the Cougars had improperly used during those seasons appeared in the highlight films. Clark sued the Cougars a second time, alleging that the appearance of the logo he designed in the highlight films was, again, copyright infringement. The Cougars assert two defenses to Clark's claim of copyright infringement the second time around.

The Cougars contended that their use of the 1996-1998 logo in the highlight films was protected by the fair use doctrine.

Since Clark and the Cougars were both citizens of Birmingham, there was no commerce among the states or interstate commerce involved, so Congress had no authority to make laws that protected Clark's copyright.

Is the Cougar's use of the logo on the highlight films protected by the fair use doctrine?

Is the Cougar's claim that Congress does not have the power to regulate copyright within a single state valid?

As you answer these two questions about the Cougar's use of the logo, explain how the evolution of the Commerce Clause of the Constitution of the United States affects businesses and the Cougars in particular.

Reference no: EM133097556

Questions Cloud

About definition of term flotation costs : Thinking about the definition of the term "flotation costs," should we expect the flotation costs for debt to be significantly lower than those for equity?

Civil litigation and arbitration : Civil litigation and arbitration (one of the forms of alternative dispute resolution) are similar in the approach that they use to resolve legal disputes.

Dispute select independent arbitrator : The parties to the dispute select an independent arbitrator who hears evidence from both parties and decides how the dispute should be resolved.

United states created our system of federal government : The Constitution of the United States created our system of federal government and allocated the powers of government among the three branches of government;

Highlight films was protected by the fair use doctrine : The Cougars contended that their use of the 1996-1998 logo in the highlight films was protected by the fair use doctrine.

Geofencing on campus to improve student life and safety : How could a university leverage the benefits of geofencing on campus to improve student life and safety?

Partner in small communications firm : As a partner in a small communications firm, you have noticed that your fellow partners and several employees have mentioned new product ideas

Test quantitative designs : Pre-test/post-test quantitative designs have been the subject of criticism among methodologists.

Conduct survey to measure business optimism : An organization representing the interests of small businesses in London plans to conduct a survey to measure business optimism,

User Account

All Pages