Highlight films protected by the fair use doctrine

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM133200910 , Length: 2 pages

Scenario

Jim Clark, an artist in Birmingham, submitted his logo design for the Birmingham Cougars football team, and the Cougars used a logo design that was very similar to Clark's design for their team logo during the 1996-1998 seasons. Clark sued the Cougars for copyright infringement for using his design as their logo without his permission, and the court ruled that the Cougars had improperly used Clark's design for their logo and had infringed on his copyright of that design.

The Cougars changed their logo for the 1999 season, but they started showing highlight films from their 1996-1998 seasons in their stadium, on their website, and on their television channel, and the logo that Clark had designed and that the Cougars had improperly used during those seasons appeared in the highlight films.

Clark sued the Cougars a second time, alleging that the appearance of the logo he designed in the highlight films was, again, copyright infringement.

The Cougars assert two defenses to Clark's claim of copyright infringement the second time around.

The Cougars contended that their use of the 1996-1998 logo in the highlight films was protected by the fair use doctrine.

Since Clark and the Cougars were both citizens of Birmingham, there was no commerce among the states or interstate commerce involved, so Congress had no authority to make laws that protected Clark's copyright.

In a two-page case study, address the questions below.
Is the Cougar's use of the logo on the highlight films protected by the fair use doctrine?
Is the Cougar's claim that Congress does not have the power to regulate copyright within a single state valid?

As you answer these two questions about the Cougar's use of the logo, explain how the evolution of the Commerce Clause of the Constitution of the United States affects businesses and the Cougars in particular. Also, be sure to address the categories of intellectual properties protected by the Constitution of the United States.

Your case study should be at least two pages in length and include at least two outside sources. Be sure to use APA formatting for all citations and references. Please note that no abstract is needed.

The Legal Citations tutorial may be helpful in citing legal documents.

Reference no: EM133200910

Questions Cloud

Calculate taxes-investment-public savings : If G increases so that now G = 2.5, recalculate Public Savings, National Savings and Investment. College of San Mateo. Econ 100.

Briefly summarize the pricing strategy of company researched : MKT 402 Strayer University. Use Internet and Strayer Library to find that company's pricing strategy. Briefly summarize pricing strategy of company researched.

Evaluate the importance of the standard default clause : LEG 440 Strayer University - Evaluate the importance of the standard default clause. As a contracts officer for the DOE, suggest two ways in which you could

Benefits of tesla being first in mass-produced electric car : What are the advantages to Tesla being the first in the mass-produced electric car market? What advantages do the other auto manufacturers have over Tesla

Highlight films protected by the fair use doctrine : Clark sued the Cougars a second time, alleging that the appearance of the logo he designed in the highlight films was, again, copyright infringement

Narayana hrudayalaya heart hospital : Would you describe this heart hospital as successful? Explain why.

Determine consumption and investment : What determines the amount of output an economy produces? What determines consumption and investment?

Business processes using the bpmn diagram : Students should model the following business processes using the BPMN diagram for each scenario. Click each of the scenarios below to find out further about eac

Factors impacting digital payment adoption : Carefully read the paper: "Factors Impacting Digital Payment Adoption: An Empirical Evidence from the Smart City of Dubai".

User Account

All Pages