Reference no: EM132102224
Closing Case: Hard Facts and Half-Truths
Case Summary
Stanford University professors Jeffrey Pfeffer and Bob Sutton, authors of Hard Facts, Dangerous Half-Truths, and Total Nonsense, have put out a call for a renewed reliance on rationality in managerial decision making—an approach that they call evidence-based management (EBM). They define evidence-based management as “a commitment to finding and using the best theory and data available at the time to make decisions,” but their “Five Principles of Evidence-Based Management” make it clear that EBM means more than just sifting through data and crunching numbers. Pfeffer and Sutton’s research shows that pay-for-performance policies get good results when employees work solo or independently. But it’s another matter altogether when it comes to the kind of collaborative teams that make so many organizational decisions today. According to Pfeffer and Sutton, wide disparities in pay often weaken both trust among team members and the social connectivity that contributes to strong, team-based decision making. Or consider another increasingly prevalent policy for evaluating and rewarding talent. Pfeffer and Sutton found that, according to many HR managers, forced ranking impaired morale and collaboration and ultimately reduced productivity.
Case Questions
1. Do you think evidence-based management seems like common sense? If so, why wasn’t it advocated earlier?
2. Are there circumstances in which evidence-based management might not be the best approach?
3. Could automated evidence-based management ever replace human decision makers? Why, or why not?
4. Would you want your work under Jack Welch’s system at General Electric? Why, or why not?
Pros and cons of top-down approach to global marketing
: What are the pros and cons of a top-down approach to global marketing?
|
About planning and time management
: About Planning & time Management related to Management Consulting?
|
Logo that appears on silk-screened t-shirt
: Consider the example of a unique design or logo that appears on a silk-screened T-shirt.
|
Based on working definition of strategy with text book
: evaluate Fisher’s efforts in the digital market, based on working definition of strategy with text book, how would we evaluate the effectiveness of strategy?
|
Hard facts and half-truths
: Stanford University professors Jeffrey Pfeffer and Bob Sutton, authors of Hard Facts, Dangerous Half-Truths, and Total Nonsense,
|
Other major players also announced cuts
: Other "major" players also announced cuts. Why are shoppers not frequenting JCPenney’s, Macy’s, Sears, K-Mart, etc.?
|
Main issues facing businesses today in small local markets
: What are some of the main issues facing businesses today in small local markets? Discuss the problems.
|
Provide rationale that might support each approach
: Many training approaches in aviation are linear by design. Contrast these two approaches, then provide a rationale that might support each approach.
|
The difference in barbara minto the pyramid principle
: Deduction and induction: the difference in Barbara Minto’s The Pyramid Principle.
|