Hanousek criminally liable for violating statute regardless

Assignment Help Operation Management

Reference no: EM13899034

Edward Hanousek worked for Pacific and Arctic Railway and Navigation Company (P&A) as a road master of the White Pass & Yukon Railroad in Alaska. Hanousek was responsible "for every detail of the safe and efficient maintenance and construction of track, structures and marine facilities of the entire railroad," including special projects. One project was a rock quarry, known as "6-mile," above the Skagway River. Next to the quarry, and just beneath the surface, ran a high-pressure oil pipeline owned by Pacific and Arctic Pipeline, Inc. P&A's sister company. When the quarry's backhoe operator punctured the pipeline, an estimated 1,000-5,000 gallons of oil were discharged into the river. Hanousek was charged with negligently discharging a harmful quantity of oil into a navigable water of the United States in violation of the criminal provisions of the Clean Water Act (CWA). Using the information presented in the chapter, answer the following questions.

1. Did Hanousek have the required mental state (mens rea) to be convicted of a crime? Why or why not?

2. Which theory discussed in the chapter would enable a court to hold Hanousek criminally liable for violating the statute regardless of whether he participated in, directed, or even knew about the specific violation?

3. Could the backhoe operator who punctured the pipeline also be charged with a crime in this situation? Explain.

4. Suppose that at trial, Hanousek argued that he should not be convicted because he was not aware of the requirements of the SWA. Would this defense be successful? Why or why not?

Reference no: EM13899034

Questions Cloud

Describe about fair-minded qualities : Descreption about Fair-Minded Qualities

Discuss difference between management and leadership : Discuss the difference between “Management” and “Leadership” in relation to how they may lead to different behaviors of employees. Assess the impact of situational leadership methods on organizational performance in the following situation - An organ..

Encourage executives to misrepresent financial performance : What external pressures encourage executives to misrepresent financial performance? How can companies prevent this type of behavior?

How be would you draw the shape of such an isoquant curve : The nursing output consists of two specific types of output - How be would you draw the shape of such an isoquant curve?

Hanousek criminally liable for violating statute regardless : Edward Hanousek worked for Pacific and Arctic Railway and Navigation Company (P&A) as a road master of the White Pass & Yukon Railroad in Alaska. Did Hanousek have the required mental state (mens rea) to be convicted of a crime? Why or why not? Which..

Shows a weak relationship between the variables : Explain the difference between the information given by the tests of statistical significance t and Chi Square, and measures of association Cramer's V, Gamma and Pearson's correlation coefficient, r.

What is management''s role in the transformational change? : What is management's role in the transformational change?

What are the four requirements of a valid contract? : Mitsui Bank hired Ross Duncan as a branch manager in one of its Southern California location. At that time, Duncan received an employee handbook informing him that Mitsui would review his performance and salary level annually. What are the four requi..

Summarize the effectiveness of the project process : Summarize the effectiveness of the project process. Francis (2015) provides this checklist to follow when handing over a project: Project documentation (risk and issue logs, project plan and charter, project schedule, etc.)

User Account

All Pages