Greater case standing for excesses of litigation

Assignment Help Operation Management

Reference no: EM132137681

Perhaps, there is no greater case standing for the excesses of litigation than the McDonald's Coffee case. If you are not familiar with this case, Mrs. Stella Liebeck (79 years old) was riding shotgun in the McDonald's drive-thru and ordered a cup of coffee. She set the cup of coffee between her legs and as her son took off, the lid on the coffee came loose resulting in scalding hot coffee burning Mrs. Liebeck's groin. She sued McDonald's alleging several different theories including breach of warranty. At the conclusion of her jury trial, Mrs. Liebeck received $160,000 in compensatory damages and $2.7 million in punitive damages, much to the outrage of the general public. In fact, in one of the great television parodies on this case and our legal system, an episode of Seinfeld lampooned Mrs. Liebeck's result

But if we dig deeper, you might find some interesting facts about Mrs. Liebeck's case. For example:

McDonald's served its coffee generally at 180-190 degrees Faherenheit.

During discovery, McDonald's had faced more than 700 claims by customers who had been burned by their coffee between 1982 and 1992.

Generally, most other establishments serve coffee at 135-140 degrees.

McDonald's quality assurance manager testified that burn hazards exist on any food substance served above 140 degrees.

Mrs. Liebeck required a vascular surgeon to repair her burns by skin graft over 6% of her body.

The trial court reduced the punitive damage award to $480,000.

Mrs. Liebeck initially offered to settle for $20,000 to cover her medical costs. McDonald's refused.

The questions to be discussed this week are as follows: Do you think McDonald's breached it's implied warranty when it sold Ms Liebeck her coffee? Do you think the trial court should have downwardly reduced the punitive damages award from $2.7M to $480K? Could there be any business justification for McDonald's to essentially ignore the 700 claims for hot coffee made between 1982-1992? Explain.

Reference no: EM132137681

Questions Cloud

Why is it important for the manager to consider relationship : Why is it important for the manager to consider this relationship?

How the processes relate to each other : Evaluate the processes that are involved in a systems development lifecycle (SDLC) and how the processes relate to each other.

Write a blog post about your bucket list : Write a blog post about your Bucket List (8-12 things you want to do before you die), or a Top Ten List, which you can interpret as you choose.

Describe how would you decide if the best option : The decision to globalize operations is very complex and not without risks. Chose a company that has not yet globalized and answer the following:

Greater case standing for excesses of litigation : Perhaps, there is no greater case standing for the excesses of litigation than the McDonald's Coffee case.

Why does out of date stock need to be disposed of : Why does out of date stock need to be disposed of? What records need to be kept when disposing of out of date stock? Where should these records be stored?

What major do you plan to pursue : What major do you plan to pursue? Here we will do a mini example essay in class about the different careers you might be able to pursue with your degree.

Examples of national quality control models : Examples of national quality control models? Whats are the key concepts?

How the cultures of the ancient western world shaped : Identify how the cultures of the ancient Western World (for our purposes, Mesopotamia, Greece, and Rome) shaped Western forms of government.

User Account

All Pages