Fourth Amendment protection

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM133041619

In Carroll v. United States, the Supreme Court held that vehicles were held to a lesser standard of Fourth Amendment protection by stating that a warrant wasn't required. Then, in Katz v. United States, the Court established the right to privacy as a defense against warrantless searches. Fast forward to 45 years after the Katz decision and we have the United States v. Jones case. This case was an appeal from the District of Columbia Circuit Court of Appeals that went on to the Supreme Court, on the issue of whether a warrant is needed to attach a GPS tracking device to a vehicle.

1. Is it a reasonable progression based on the Court's analysis to require a warrant before the government places a GPS on a vehicle? Why or why not?

2. Based on the Court's interpretation of the right to privacy under the 4th Amendment, should a warrant be required to place a GPS? Why or why not?

3. Assuming that a warrant is required, what are the exceptions to this requirement that might apply when the government legally places a GPS on a vehicle?

Reference no: EM133041619

Questions Cloud

Saving and investing as two separate steps : Economists talk about saving and investing as two separate steps. After an individual has saved some money, it's time to decide on investments.
Capital punishment by religious leaders for several decades : Christians are to call out against capital punishment by religious leaders for several decades.
Public policy makers and main stakeholders facing : What kinds of challenges are public policy makers and main stakeholders facing? identify major tasks and challenges by these identified actors and stakeholders.
Explain how investigators process crime scene : Explain how investigators process a crime scene. Describe the process of removing a child from their home and placing him/her into protective custody.
Fourth Amendment protection : The Supreme Court held that vehicles were held to a lesser standard of Fourth Amendment protection by stating that a warrant wasn't required
Explain neighbour principle : Explain "neighbour principle" as stated by Lord Atkin in Donoghue v Stevenson. 2. In relation to the law of tort, explain legal term "contributory negligene"
Intellectual property patents-trademarks and copyrights : Explain the three main types of intellectual property Patents, Trademarks and Copyrights.
Types and levels of formal power : Should governors share the same types and levels of formal power? Are there potential problem with differing levels of formal gubernatorial power between states
Describe the elements of robbery : Describe the elements of a robbery. Explain how an investigator would process each of your examples.

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Describe how the unitarist and pluralist approaches

Describe how the Unitarist and Pluralist approaches to conflict would explain the positions of (a) management and (b) unions in the Aurizon dispute. Identify which one of the approaches provides the better explanation. Explain how you reached this co..

  Identify successes of lesson plan delivery

Identify successes of lesson plan delivery as well as areas of potential growth. Be sure to explain how you will use your findings in your future professional.

  Operationally defined as engaging in a phone conversation

A study finds that distraction (operationally defined as engaging in a phone conversation) affects performance (operationally defined as careful driving in a driving simulator). Design a conceptual replication.

  Discuss the fundamental actions

Select one (1) developing country, and discuss the fundamental actions that the leadership of the selected country is - or is not - taking to improve the living standards of its people

  Purpose of maintaning complete and accurate patient data

What is the importance and purpose of maintaning  complete and accurate patient data?  How would such inaccuracies in patient data affect patient care and reimbursement?

  How the problem came to public and political awareness

The scope and nature of the public policy problem. How the problem came to public and political awareness. The evolution of related public policy. Level of government and the actors involved.

  What is descartes doing in his first and second meditations

What is Descartes doing in his first and second meditations? How does he come to consider as false everything which offers only the slightest reason for doubt and how does he come to the conclusion that he is a thinking thing?

  What you think are the most important points

For your discussion post, your first step is to summarize the article in two paragraphs, describing what you think are the most important points made.

  Determine what is measured in assessing health

Write a 3 to 5 page paper that addresses the following: Describe the two assessments you chose. What data was collected in the needs assessments?

  Write a bibliography paper about running for office

Write a bibliography paper about Running for office. The assignment must have a title page and a reference page (bibliography). The body of the assignment must be 4-5 pages in length and double-spaced.

  What are the expected returns for stock x and y

What are the expected returns for stock X and Y - What are the standard deviations of returns on stocks X and Y - What are the expected returns

  Explain different ways in which californians can practice

List ALL of the differences between the U.S. federal government and the California state government in terms of the three branches (legislative, executive).

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd