Formulate a philisophical response

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM13520584

Consider the following two scenerios. Formulate a philisophical response as to what you would do in each situation and give your reasons why.

Imagine you are hiking in a secluded region and you come across a group of armed thugs threatening to kill 10 people, who you strongly suspect to be perfectly innocent. The thugs capture you, and the leader gives you a choice. He says if you personally kill one of the prisoners, he will let the remaining 9 go free; otherwise, he will kill all 10. He gives you a knife and two armed thugs escort you to the prisoner. What do you suspect you would do and why?

Five of your loved ones require organ transplants to survive, but you are the only suitable organ match. If you sacrifice yourself, your organs can be used to save all of them. For the sake of the thought-experiment, assume you could legally do this. Would you do this, why or why not? Does your rationale rule out a physician sacrificing you without your consent for the same purposes?

Reference no: EM13520584

Questions Cloud

Various proofs of the existence of god : After reading about the various proofs of the existence of God, identify which of these arguments seems to be the best, and explain why you think so.
What augustine means by predestination and free will : Using quotations from On Rebuke and Grace, explain what Augustine means by “predestination” and “free will.”
Why are not there more news reports about police brutality : What issue is the speaker using to take a position in the following situation? Police brutality does not happen very often. Otherwise, it would not make headlines when it does happen. Why aren't there more news reports about police brutality?
What is real and how do we know what is real : Which answer Plato and Aristotle give to these questions: What is real And How do we know what is real? How would Aristotle explain what it is to be human?
Formulate a philisophical response : Imagine you are hiking in a secluded region and you come across a group of armed thugs threatening to kill 10 people, who you strongly suspect to be perfectly innocent. The thugs capture you, and the leader gives you a choice. He says if you perso..
Difference between subjective claims and objective claims : Explain how you would teach the difference between subjective claims and objective claims to someone who had never heard of critical thinking.
A hypothetical case : A hypothetical case and question You are a medical researcher who has discovered a means to cure mentally ill people. The people you can "cure" do not know who they are or who you are.
Is being off the grid possible in your current profession : Which specific electronic device or appliance could you not live without? Could you go “off the grid”? What might be good about going off the grid? Is being off the grid possible in your current profession?
Why bother changing a corrupt constitution : Whose advice is most practical?  Why bother changing a corrupt constitution (Politeia)?

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Recognize which of two paragraphs was more effective

Recognize which of two selected paragraphs was more effective, focusing on writing elements rather than opinions presented.

  Types of crimes outlined by beccaria

The degree of dispersion of scores around the mean is known as the. Which of the following was not one of the three types of crimes outlined by Beccaria?

  Tricyclic antidepressants are highly toxic

Some research has supported the hypothesis that depressed people think more negatively than others because their thinking is unrealistic or distorted. Tricyclic antidepressants are highly toxic. In bipolar disorder, the initial episode for men is usu..

  Before the building of the canal had even begun

Before the building of the Canal had even begun, the U.S. had to tackle the problem of:

  Describe how a biopsychosocial approach

Jack is a second-grade student. He seems to have no interest in learning, often daydreaming in class and frequently disrupting the class by throwing objects at other students.

  Protect the design of smoothglide from competitors

What steps should Dracca take to protect the design of SmoothGlide from competitors? What actions (internal and external) do you recommend to Dracca to remedy the ethical and legal considerations of this scenario? Be specific and detailed, and be sur..

  Role of the project champion

Which of the following responsibilities are typically NOT part of the role of the project champion? A Eliminates barriers B Ensures availability of resources C Communicates progress of team to upper management D Supervises daily process operations

  Individuality is not inborn but acquired

Your text book states, “Individuality is not inborn but acquired” (Ruggiero, 2009, p. 52). What are some of the steps you can take to become an individual?

  Describe and evaluate audi’s brand building initiatives

Describe and evaluate Audi’s brand building initiatives. How important are quality gains to Audi in closing the revenue gap with BMW and Mercedes? Discuss the role of SUV models in Audi’s competitive strategy.

  Management team

The company is looking to bring in a new, top management team. Employees who consistently remained with the organization are valuable assets because the longer they stay on the job, the more opportunity they have to learn and grow as individual and b..

  What are the tasks the subtasks the work packageshow do you

part one read the executive summary p. 3 of the gauchito project plan final file and the project charter pp. 99-104 of

  Hottest topics in the 90''s was the development

One of the hottest topics in the 90's was the development and use of teams within the organization, particularly self-managed work teams. A reason frequently cited for support of these self-managed teams is that they reduce the number of managers req..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd