Factors in designing an effective selection process

Assignment Help Business Management

Reference no: EM131163992

The Pole Climbers
Ringing Bell Telephone Company has implemented an affirmative action plan in compliance with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. Under the current plan, to eliminate discrimination based on sex, women must be placed in jobs traditionally held by men. Therefore, the human resource department has emphasized recruiting and hiring women for such positions. Women who apply for craft positions are encouraged to try for outdoor craft jobs, such as those titled installer-repairer and line worker.

All employees hired as outside technicians must first pass basic installation school, which includes a week of training for pole climbing. During this week, employees are taught to climb 30-foot telephone poles. At the end of the week, they must demonstrate the strength and skills necessary to climb the pole and perform exercises while on it, such as lifting heavy tools and using a pulley to lift a bucket. Only those who pass this first week of training are allowed to advance to the segment dealing with installation. Records have been maintained on the rates of success or failure for employees who attend the training school. For men, the failure rate has remained fairly constant at 30 percent. However, it has averaged 70 percent for women.

The human resource department has become concerned because hiring and training employees who must resign at the end of one week is a tremendous expense. In addition, the goal of placing women in outdoor craft positions is not being reached. As a first step in solving the problem, the human resource department has started interviewing the women who have failed the first week of training. Each employee is asked her reasons for seeking the position and encouraged to discuss probable causes for failure.

Interviews over the last two months disclosed that employees were motivated to accept the job because of their wishes to work outdoors, work without close supervision, obtain challenging work, meet the public, have variety in their jobs, and obtain a type of job unusual for women. Reasons for failure were physical inability to climb the pole, fear of height while on it, an accident during training such as a fall from the pole, and a change of mind about the job after learning that strenuous work was involved. In many instances, the women who mentioned physical reasons also stated they were not physically ready to undertake the training; many had no idea it would be so difficult. Even though they still wanted the job, they could not pass the physical strength test at the end of one week.

Some stated that they felt "influenced" by their interviewer from the human resource department to take the job; others said they had accepted it because it was the only job available with the company at the time.

QUESTIONS

1. What factors would you keep in mind in designing an effective selection process for the position of outdoor craft technician?

2. What would you recommend to help Ringing Bell reduce the failure rate among women trainees?

Reference no: EM131163992

Questions Cloud

Write out your budget set using mathematical set notation : Consider commodity space where x1 is food and x2 is everything else. Allow food to have the price p1, and allow everything else to have the price of dollars, so p2 = $1. Denote income as m. Write out your budget set using mathematical set notation.

Organizations should able to hire employees : "Organizations should be able to hire employees without government interference." - Do you agree or disagree?

Examines strategies to provide some increased safety : The third portion examines strategies to provide some increased safety. In this last section write about some of the current suggestions that can keep your machine and especially your data safe.

Select five to seven leadership concepts : Select five to seven leadership concepts that were presented in class (listed below) to describe and evaluate for this assignment. Discuss the different ethical aspects of each of the five to seven concepts you selected as they relate to your ind..

Factors in designing an effective selection process : What factors would you keep in mind in designing an effective selection process for the position of outdoor craft technician?

Explain the concept of mark-to-funding accounting rule : Explain the concept of mark-to-funding accounting rule, proposed by Brunnermeier Et.al.(2009) ? How can this rule help reduce the problem caused by the mark-to-market rule ?

What are potential benefit and risk with penetration testing : Choose a side and argue for or against hiring an outside company. What are the potential benefits and risks with penetration testing in general.

Is it ethical for leaders to try to increase their power : Do you agree? Considering this idea, is it ethical for leaders to try to increase their power? In your discussion, include two examples form real life, personal or professional, and how they tie into the concept of absolute power/control.

Define reliability and validity : define "reliability" and "validity." -- What trends over the last several decades have made employee selection critical for manufacturers?

User Account

All Pages