Explaining the objective theory of contracts

Reference no: EM1328401

You are still working for the City of Bigtown's Counsel, and it seems that your work largely involves shooting down the mayor's "creative" ideas to boost tourism. He is taken with the idea of an advertising campaign developed around auctioning Bigtown on eBay! He thinks that no one will take the auction seriously but that people will come to Bigtown to satisfy their curiosity.

As you and your boss are rolling your eyes at each other, you remember a similar situation - the Pepsi Harrier-Jet case. You offer to provide background

LEAD STORY-DATELINE:
Wall Street Journal, August 9, 1999.
John D.R. Leonard took PepsiCo seriously when one of their "Pepsistuff" commercials made an offer of a Harrier jet, the famous high-tech "jump jet" used by the U.S. Marines. In a TV commercial that aired in 1995, Pepsi jokingly included the Harrier as one of the prizes that could be received with a "mere" 7 million Pepsi points. While that sounds like a lot of points to get from drinking Pepsi products (roughly 190 Pepsis a day for 100 years), the company also allowed customers to purchase points for 10 cents a piece.

Leonard did the math, and discovered that the cost of the 7 million points needed for the jet was a mere $700,000. He then put together a business plan, raised the $700,000 from friends and family, and submitted 15 Pepsi points, the check, and an official order form along with a demand for the Harrier jet.

PepsiCo wrote back, stating: "The Harrier jet in the Pepsi commercial is fanciful and is simply included to create a humorous and entertaining ad. We apologize for any misunderstanding or confusion that you may have experienced and are enclosing some free product coupons for your use."

The free coupons did not satisfy Leonard, who then took PepsiCo to task in court. Finally, on August 5, 1999, a federal judge for the Southern District of New York held that PepsiCo was only joking when it implied in its ad that it was giving away fighter jets. Judge Wood noted that since the jets sell for approximately $23 million each, "no objective person could reasonably have concluded that the commercial actually offered consumers a Harrier jet." Instead, this was a classic example of "a deal too good to be true."

1) What are the four elements of a valid contract?

2) Describe the objective theory of contracts. How does that theory apply to this case?

3)Why do you think the court held that there was not a valid agreement here?

4) Are advertisements generally considered offers? Why or why not?

5) How does this case differ from a reward situation, where a unilateral contract is formed upon completion of the requested act?

Reference no: EM1328401

Questions Cloud

Lottery requires that you select six different numbers : A lottery needs that you select six different numbers from the integers 1 to 49. Write a Java program that will do this for you and generate five sets of six numbers as a result.

Management strategies to employ in current position : What management strategies can you employ in your current position (even if you are not yet a manager)?

Prepare a systems development plan : Create a systems development plan/efficient use of data - What lessons can be learned from creating a systems development plan and how can it help you contribute to current or future workplace settings?

As customers will more price sensitive also price conscious : Do you think we, as customers will be more price sensitive also price conscious. What do you think this means for luxury goods.

Explaining the objective theory of contracts : You are still working for the City of Bigtown's Counsel, and it seems that your work largely involves shooting down the mayor's "creative" ideas to boost tourism.

Interest-future value-present value : Computing Present Values - You've just received notification which you have won the $1 million first prize in Centennial Lottery. However, the prize will be awarded on your 100th birthday (assuming you're around to collect), 80 years from now. What..

It based partnerships in logistics or manufacturing : Why do many business partnerships—such as non-information-technology (IT)-based partnerships in logistics or manufacturing—fail?

Show the analysis of control procedures : What type of fraud do you consider to be most damaging to an organization and Of the analysis of control procedures, which do your prefer?

How can small business owners minimize the risks : Many small businesses are built around one product. What risks does this approach impose? How can small business owners minimize those risks?

User Account

All Pages