Explain which of the two grammars is preferable and why

Assignment Help English
Reference no: EM13796900

Exercise 3 Pronouns and coreference

Part A

This exercise flows on from the last two, but looks at how pronouns and reflexives are distributed. Consider the following data:

(1) *I kicked me

(2) I kicked myself.

(3) You kicked you

(4) You kicked yourself.

(5) *We kicked us

(6) We kicked ourselves.

Task 1 We can formulate a hypothesis to cover these data, using the same kinds of concepts. We will term this the Pronoun Generalization:

(7) A pronoun cannot be coreferential with another pronoun.

Task 2 Explain how this hypothesis extends to the following data:

(8) He kicked him.

(9) They kicked them.

(10) She kicked her.

Part B

Recall the two grammars that you chose between in the last exercise. Grammar A stated that imperatives had an unpronounced subject, while grammar B stated that imperatives had no subject at all, but that only second-person reflexives could appear in imperatives.

Now consider the following data:

(11) Kick me!

(12) Kick them!

(13) *Kick you!

Task 3 Assume Grammar A is the correct grammar, and that the Pronoun Generalization holds. Explain how the new data given above fall out in this grammar.

Task 4 Assume Grammar B is the correct grammar, and that the Pronoun Generalization holds. Explain how the new data don't immediately follow, and revise Grammar B by adding a new hypothesis to fix it.

Task 5 Now explain which of the two grammars is preferable, and why.

Further reading

Section 2.2

The notion of features in syntax derives from work on features in phonology. See Chomsky and Halle (1968) for discussion and further references. Matthews (1974) gives an overview of many of the kinds of morphological processes that are found in languages. For a more detailed overview of issues in morphology see the papers in Spencer and Zwicky (1998).

Section 2.3

See Dalrymple and Kaplan (2000) for a discussion of some of the issues raised by the text, and Harley and Ritter (2001) for an alternative using feature geometry. The Hopi data are taken from the latter source. An excellent descriptive discussion of constraints on how languages vary with respect to the features they use is Greenberg (1966). The idea that morphology and semantics are both interpretative components of grammar goes back to early work of Chomsky (see Chomsky, 1970).

Reference no: EM13796900

Questions Cloud

Describe managed care services cost and utilization : Define basic terminology/features of health insurance and describe managed care services cost and utilization control tools relating to insurance reimbursement.
Board of governors of the federal reserve website : 1. Base your answer on yearly data from the following series that is available from Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve Website via the DDP Program. 10-year Treasury constant maturity (H15/H15/RIFLGFCY10_N.M) Moody's Aaa (H15/H15/RIMLPAAAR_N...
Problems related to limitations of your selected biometric : When reviewing 2 other student responses, choose a different biometric.
Individual assignment health care information systems : Individual Assignment Health Care Information Systems Terms
Explain which of the two grammars is preferable and why : Now explain which of the two grammars is preferable, and why. We can formulate a hypothesis to cover these data, using the same kinds of concepts. We will term this the Pronoun Generalization.
Concepts of class and individual characteristics of evidence : Now that you have educated the new investigator on the concepts of class and individual characteristics of evidence, it is time to begin collecting the evidence that you had marked during the initial walk-through. In this assignment, you address t..
Offshoring and offshoring outsourcing : Offshoring and offshoring outsourcing
Describe an understanding of operational management theory : Explain the historical evolution of health care quality improvement programs. Demonstrate an understanding of operational management theory.
The concept of interprofessional collaboration issues : What negative outcomes will likely occur if the patient does not receive the care offered by the allied health provider?

Reviews

Write a Review

English Questions & Answers

  Write a profile

Write a profile on bishop poleni.

  Education system

Write a rearch paper on education system

  Write an report

The U.S. President Barack Obama said America can "win the future" by rebuilding its manufacturing sector (on June 8, 2011, after visiting an automotive training center at a community college in Virginia, outside Washington). Do you agree, and why?

  Discuss the accuracy of this statement

'Consideration does not have to be adequate or commercially realistic, nor does it need to be expressed in monetary terms, it merely needs to be "sufficient".' Discuss the accuracy of this statement.

  Write an essay on the youngest billionaire

Write an essay on the youngest billionaire

  Transformational leadership in the public sector

The more hierarchical an organization's authority structure, the lower the reported practice of transformational leadership behaviors.

  Modal verbs or modal constructions

Identify all the modal verbs or modal constructions in the passage

  Write a latter to mom thanking to adopting and caring

Write a latter to mom thanking for adopting and caring,

  Ways of knowing & authority in your discipline

To explore and become familiar with your discipline; to prepare you for your major researched essay.

  Writing an effective business letter

Prepare a letter in either block or modified block format, addressed to your employer or supervisor and copied to your marker.

  Discuss the kingdom of saudi arabia

Discuss the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia

  Developing an annotated bibliography

Developing an annotated bibliography

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd