Explain whether utah correctly predicts interpretation

Assignment Help English
Reference no: EM13792869

Exercise 1- UTAH

Task 1- Give derivations, along the lines of that given in the text, for the vPs in the following two sentences:

(1) Romeo sent letters to Juliet.

(2) Romeo sent Juliet letters.

Task 2- Explain whether the UTAH correctly predicts the interpretation for these sentences.

There have been a number of proposals in the literature about how to reconcile the UTAH and these two constructions. See the Further reading section.

Exercise 2- Pronouns and c-command

This exercise and the next give you some practice with incorporating the notion of c-command into syntactic arguments. You are already familiar with the Pronoun Generalization.

(1) The Pronoun Generalization

A pronoun cannot be co-referential with another pronoun.

Part A-

Task 1- For each of the following sentences, say whether the grammaticality judgment given is predicted by the Pronoun Generalization, on the assumption that the words in bold are co-referential, and explain why you think the judgment is predicted or not:

(2) Anson kissed him.

(3) Moya played football with her

(4) 'She intended Jenny to be there

Part B-

Task 2- Now assume the following revised generalization, and explain how it is empirically superior:

(5) The Pronoun Generalization (revised)

A pronoun cannot be co-referential with another NP.

Part C-

Task 3- the revised generalization, however, does not predict the following cases. Briefly explain why.

(6) Moya's football team loved her.

(7) That picture of Jenny in a rubber dress doesn't flatter her.

(8) Anson's hen nibbled his ear.

The sentences which are not predicted by the Pronoun Generalization are, of course, reminiscent in their structure to those sentences which caused us to revise the Reflexive Generalization. If we revise the Pronoun Generalization in the same way, we can capture these data:

(9) The Pronoun Generalization (revised)

A pronoun cannot be co-referential with a c-commanding NP.

Task 4- Show, using replacement and movement tests, that this revised generalization makes the correct predictions for the problematic sentences.

Exercise 3- R-expressions and c-command

Part A-

Task 1- the new Pronoun Generalization does not predict the correct judgments for example (4) above or for the following sentences. Explain why.

(1) He liked Anson

(2) They shaved David and Anson

Part B-

Examples like these have prompted linguists to propose another generalization for referring expressions, like proper names. Referring expressions (often abbreviated as R-expressions) have their own reference and appear to be unable to be co-referential with any c-commanding antecedent. Here is a simplified version of that third generalization:

(3) The R-Expression Generalization

An R-expression cannot be co-referential with a c-commanding NP.

Task 2- Explain how the full set of judgments from this and the previous exercise is now explained by the three generalizations.

Part C-

We will now rephrase these three generalizations in terms of another concept: binding. We shall define binding as follows:

(4) A binds B if A c-commands B and A and B are co-referential. We can now state our three generalizations as follows:

(5) a. A reflexive must be hound.

b. A pronoun cannot be bound.

c. An R-expression cannot be bound.

Task 3- Using the terms binding, reflexive, pronoun, and R-expression, explain how the following sentences fall under the Binding Generalizations or not.

(6) His hen loves Anson.

(7) ?Anson saw Anson. (Assume that this is basically OK)

(8) That picture of her flatters Jenny.

(9) 'She liked Moya's football

(10) Moya said she liked football.

(11) She said Moya liked football we will return to the contrast between (10) and (11) in later chapters.

Exercise 4- NPls

Part A-

Task 1- Explain why (2) is problematic for the NPI Generalization and repeated here:

(1) The NPI Generalization (revised) NPIs must be c-commanded by a negative clement.

(2) No one's mother had baked anything.

Part B-

Task 2- Using NP1s, make up examples with three-place predicates, along the lines of the examples with reflexives in the text, which construct an argument for or against the VP-shell hypothesis.

Make sure you check the judgements on your examples with at least four native speakers of English.

Exercise 5- Derivations

In the text, we saw a full example derivation for a vP. You should use this as a model to construct similar derivations for the vPs in the following sentences'

(1) Anson gave Flutter to Jenny.

(2) Julie filed letters to herself.

(3) Mary fell. (Remember that fell is unaccusative.)

(4) Mary ran. (Remember that ran is unergative.)

Reference no: EM13792869

Questions Cloud

Azande witchcraft similar to science issues : How and why is Azande Witchcraft similar to science? What can we learn from this similarity?
Describe the ultimate goal of the product campaign : Describe the ultimate goal of the product campaign for the new shampoo - Discuss your methods for achieving this goal.
Discuss your methods for achieving goal : Describe the ultimate goal of the product campaign for the new shampoo - Discuss your methods for achieving goal.
Short notes on psychology of addiction : Psychology of Addiction
Explain whether utah correctly predicts interpretation : Explain whether the UTAH correctly predicts the interpretation for these sentences. This exercise and the next give you some practice with incorporating the notion of c-command into syntactic arguments.
Celebrity quality healthcare issues : Describe the contributions your selected celebrity endorsers have made to the quality of healthcare.
Explain the development of labor unions : Explain the development of labor unions. What were the issues workers faced? What were their demands? What types of unions developed and why-who was included and excluded?
Describe an agency problem within the firm : Describe an agency problem within the firm and discuss what you think is causing the problem and how the problem might be better controlled.
Number of cultures surrounding : How did the Roman Empire deal with the number of cultures surrounding them? To what extent were they influenced, and to what extent did they ignore these other cultures.

Reviews

Write a Review

English Questions & Answers

  Creat professional ppt presintation about defensive driving

Creat Professional PPT presintation about Defensive driving.

  What should be role of a good prince in society

Why does More's cast of characters resemble positions he held himself in life - what should be the role of a good prince in society?

  Valuate the nature of the apparent pollutants

Based on your evaluation of the virtual field trip found in the lab, evaluate the nature of the apparent pollutants in the small stream contained in the field trip.

  High-quality parenthetical citation

Describe what should be included in a high-quality Parenthetical citation and Just some information about the source, so that the beginning of the use of source material can be marked.

  Imagine your school is reaching out to new parents or

imagine your school is reaching out to new parents or parents-to-be in your community whose children may eventually go

  Discuss strategies from concepts of rogerian argument

Discuss some of the strategies from the concepts of the Rogerian Argument. How do these steps differ from the traditional argument structure and conclusion, and what are your thoughts about these differences?

  1 paragraph1defining and classifying seem like very similar

1 paragraph.1.defining and classifying seem like very similar activities. how do those kinds of analysis differ and how

  Discuss the influence papal patronage

Discuss the influence Papal patronage had upon High Renaissance work, especially the career of Michelangelo, whose Sistine Chapel has only recently been restored to something like its original appearance.

  What the main message of justice is in antigone

what the main message of justice is in Antigone. There seem to be several ways to interpret the text, but I can not figure out the primary lesson concerning justice.

  People are by nature social creatures this means that they

statement 1 - need a response to itpeople are by nature social creatures. this means that they will seek out a

  Explain how supernatural forces--gods

In two well developed paragraphs, explain how supernatural forces--gods, angels, and demons--interest themselves in the action of Beowulf and intervene from time to time. Focus on specific episodes and describe how supernatural forces are at work in ..

  Significance of goodmans journey through the forest

Why is this so? What was the significance of Goodman's journey through the forest? Were the events real or imagined? Do you feel his reaction is justified or does he over-react to his experience?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd