Explain what roll meant by the benchmark error

Assignment Help Portfolio Management
Reference no: EM13923331

Richard Roll, in an article on using the capital asset pricing model (CAPM) to evaluate portfolio performance, indicated that it may not be possible to evaluate portfolio man- agement ability if there is error in the benchmark used.

a. In evaluating portfolio performance, describe the general procedure, with emphasis on the bench mark employed.

b. Explain what Roll meant by the benchmark error, and identify the specific problem with this benchmark.

c. Draw a graph that shows how a portfolio that has been judged as superior relative to a "measured" security market line (SML) can be inferior relative to the "true" SML.

d. Assume that you are informed that a given portfolio manager has been evaluated as superior when compared to the DJIA, the S&P 500, and the NYSE Composite Index. Explain whether this consensus would make you feel more comfortable regarding the portfolio manager's true ability.

e. While conceding the possible problem with benchmark errors as set forth by Roll, some contend this does not mean the CAPM is incorrect, but only that there is a measurement problem when implementing the theory. Others contend that because of benchmark errors, the whole technique should be scrapped. Take and defend one of these positions.

Reference no: EM13923331

Questions Cloud

Describe how each of three performance measures is calculate : Describe how each of the three performance measures is calculated. State whether each measure assumes that the relevant risk is systematic, unsystematic, or total. Explain how each measure relates excess return and the relevant risk.
Diagram or a fully developed description : Question 1: Based on the following narrative, develop either an activity diagram or a fully developed description for the use case of Add a new vehicle to an existing policy in a car insurance system.
Description of the quality or safety issue : Post by Day 3 a description of the quality or safety issue you selected and a brief summary of the impact that this issue has on health care delivery. Describe at least one quality improvement strategy used to address this issue
Problem regarding the creating classes : The purpose of this lab is to gain experience in the design and implementation of a simple Java class.  You will create a class definition and write a simple main method that will test the methods of your class to ensure they work as expected.
Explain what roll meant by the benchmark error : Explain what Roll meant by the benchmark error, and identify the specific problem with this benchmark. In evaluating portfolio performance, describe the general procedure, with emphasis on the bench mark employed.
Type of sampling technique was used to collect the data : Enter the Data set (see next page: 50 samples of employee of two offices in Dubai & Abu Dhabi) into MINITAB stat software, run the required analysis, and answer the listed questions:
Directions for the skills based assessment : The final exam for this course is a comprehensive lab activity. You may consult with other students on this lab if you wish, but each student should submit a separate lab that represents your own work.
Completing the project follows a normal distribution : The mean time to complete a construction project is 52 weeks with a standard deviation of 3 weeks. Assuming the probability of completing the project follows a normal distribution, what is the probability of completing the project between 56 week..
Compute the sharpe measure for the market portfolio : Compute the Sharpe measure for each portfolio and the market portfolio. Compute the Treynor measure for each portfolio and the market portfolio

Reviews

Write a Review

Portfolio Management Questions & Answers

  Portfolio analysis

The stock with the lowest beta (0.76) is Apple Inc. stock. The stock with the highest beta (3.29) is Facebook Inc. stock. Beta for Apple Inc. stock is less that 1, it tells us that stock price is less volatile and risky than mark..

  Provide investment portfolio advice

Provide investment portfolio advice and management to a client.

  Evaluate total number of shares

EBV proposes to structure the investment as 5m shares of CP with FV of $5m, one-to one conversion to common, and no dividends. Total Valuation Estimated from Newco.

  Role of the imf and world bank

Economic and territorial logic of empire are not always aligned. Explain his argument in light of the role of the IMF and World Bank as forms of neo imperialism.

  Prepare a portfolio of stocks

Prepare a portfolio of stocks

  Which critically examines the benefits and risks to company

Which critically examines the benefits and risks to a company, of incorporating corporate debt into a portfolio of equity and debt.

  Compute the variance-covariance matrix

Compute the sample mean, variance, and standard deviation of these shares and compute the variance-covariance matrix V and Plot the daily share prices and daily returns for each individual asset.

  Net nominal rate of interest and net real rate of interest

What bank portfolio can guarantee the rate of return 1 to all type 1 people and the rate of return 1.2 to all type 2 people? How many goods are placed in storage? In capital?

  Right issue to improve financial status

If you are the CEO of a British company that now faces the loss of a lucrative contract in Malaysia because of the dispute. What action should you take and How do you think British government should respond to the Malaysian action?

  Calculate the cost of reinvested profits

Calculate the cost of reinvested profits and the cost of new common shares using the constant-growth DVM - Cost of reinvested profits versus new common shares-DVM

  Calculate the after-tax cost of debt

Cost of debt For each of the following bonds, calculate the after-tax cost of debt. Assume the coupons are paid semi-annually, that the tax rate is 40 percent, and that we are dealing with $1,000 of par value.

  Calculate the overall cost of capital for cartwell products

Calculate the overall cost of capital for Cartwell Products. Which projects should the firm select? Does your answer differ from your answer topart d? If so, explain why.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd